Arizona v. Navajo Nation

Questions presented

SCOTUS records, cert granted 4 Nov 2022

The Consolidated Decree in Arizona v. California, 547 U.S. 150 (2006), apportions the mainstream of the Colorado River in the Lower Basin ("LBCR") among three States, decrees rights to the LBCR for five Indian Reservations (but not the Navajo reservation) and various other entities, and prescribes how the Secretary of the Interior ("Secretary") shall operate the mainstream dams in satisfaction of the decreed rights and water delivery contracts entered under the Boulder Canyon Project Act ("BCPA''). The Court retained exclusive jurisdiction "for the purpose of any order, direction, or modification of the decree, or any supplementary decree, that may at any time be deemed proper in relation to the subject matter in controversy." Id. at 166-67 (emphasis added). The United States "assumes Indian trust responsibilities only to the extent it expressly accepts those responsibilities by statute," treaty, or regulation. U.S. v. Jicarilla Apache Nation, 564 U.S. 162, 176-77 (2011). The federal treaties with the Navajo Nation ("Nation") do not require the Secretary to develop a plan to secure water for the Nation; and they do not address water at all. The doctrine of implied rights to water in Winters v. United States, 426 U.S. 207 (1908) ("Winters Doctrine") cannot justify imposing such a fiduciary duty on the Secretary. The questions presented are: I. Does the Ninth Circuit Opinion, allowing the Nation to proceed with a claim to enjoin the Secretary to develop a plan to meet the Nation's water needs and manage the mainstream of the LBCR so as not to interfere with that plan, infringe upon this Court's retained and exclusive jurisdiction over the allocation of water from the LBCR mainstream in Arizona v. California? II. Can the Nation state a cognizable claim for breach of trust consistent with this Court's holding in Jicarilla based solely on unquantified implied rights to water under the Winters Doctrine?

Opinion summary

Etalia.ai summary of the majority opinion

The dispute was whether the 1868 treaty creating the Navajo Reservation required the United States to take affirmative steps to secure water for the Navajo Nation, such as assessing its water needs, planning for water supply, or building water infrastructure. Justice Kavanaugh wrote that the treaty reserved the water needed to make the reservation work, but it did not impose a duty on the United States to do more than avoid interfering with those reserved rights. The Court said breach of trust claims require specific rights-creating or duty-imposing text, and the treaty contains no such language about affirmative water obligations. The Court also rejected the Tribe’s reliance on the reservation’s status as a permanent home, other specific duties in the treaty, control over reserved rights, and treaty history. It reversed the Ninth Circuit.

Dissent summary

Etalia.ai summary of the dissenting opinions

Justice Gorsuch, joined by Justices Sotomayor, Kagan, and Jackson, dissented. He said the Court misunderstood the case and rejected a request the Navajo Nation never made. In his view, the Tribe was only asking the United States to identify the water rights it already holds in trust for the Nation and, if any had been misappropriated, to plan to stop doing so prospectively. He argued the Nation had enforceable treaty water rights, the United States holds some of them in trust, and their scope has never been assessed. He would have affirmed the Ninth Circuit and allowed the case to proceed.

Opinion written by Justice Kavanaugh

Decided 22 Jun 2023 · Official report

599us1r44_54l8.pdfOpen in a new tab

Oral argument transcript

Argued 20 Mar 2023

21-1484_7647.pdfOpen in a new tab