Moore v. Harper

Questions presented

SCOTUS records, cert granted 30 Jun 2022

Whether a State's judicial branch may nullify the regulations governing the "Manner of holding Elections for Senators and Representatives . . . prescribed . . . by the Legislature thereof," U.S. CONST. art. I, § 4, cl. 1, and replace them with regulations of the state courts' own devising, based on vague state constitutional provisions purportedly vesting the state judiciary with power to prescribe whatever rules it deems appropriate to ensure a "fair" or "free" election.

Opinion summary

Etalia.ai summary of the majority opinion

The case asked whether the Elections Clause lets state legislatures regulate federal elections free from state constitutional limits. North Carolina’s legislature drew a congressional map that was challenged as an impermissible partisan gerrymander under the North Carolina Constitution. Chief Justice Roberts, writing for the Court, held that the Elections Clause does not give state legislatures exclusive and independent authority. State legislatures remain bound by ordinary state constitutional restraints, and the Court relied on prior decisions including Hildebrant, Smiley, and Arizona State Legislature. The Court also held that it had jurisdiction because the federal issue remained live despite later state-court proceedings. The Court affirmed the North Carolina Supreme Court, though it said federal courts must still ensure state courts do not evade federal law and did not decide whether the North Carolina court exceeded those limits because petitioners had not properly presented that issue.

Dissent summary

Etalia.ai summary of the dissenting opinions

Justice Thomas dissented, joined by Justice Gorsuch and by Justice Alito as to Part I. He argued that the case was moot because the North Carolina courts later resolved the underlying dispute in petitioners’ favor, so the federal question could not affect the final judgment. He said the majority was issuing an advisory opinion about a federal defense that no longer mattered. He also criticized the majority for treating the case as involving a freestanding judgment about the statute rather than the parties’ rights in the litigation.

Opinion written by Justice Roberts

Decided 27 Jun 2023 · Official report

600us1r50_h3ci.pdfOpen in a new tab

Oral argument transcript

Argued 7 Dec 2022

21-1271_2k81.pdfOpen in a new tab