Jones v. Hendrix

Questions presented

SCOTUS records, cert granted 16 May 2022

Under 28 U.S.C. § 2255, federal inmates can collaterally challenge their convictions on any ground cognizable on collateral review, with successive attacks limited to certain claims that indicate factual innocence or that rely on constitutional-law decisions made retroactive by this Court. 28 U.S.C. § 2255(h). 28 U.S.C. § 2255(e), however, also allows inmates to collaterally challenge their convictions outside this process through a traditional habeas action under 28 U.S.C. § 2241 whenever it "appears that the remedy by [§ 2255] motion is inadequate or ineffective to test the legality of [their] detention." The question presented is whether federal inmates who did not-because established circuit precedent stood firmly against them-challenge their convictions on the ground that the statute of conviction did not criminalize their activity may apply for habeas relief under § 2241 after this Court later makes clear in a retroactively applicable decision that the circuit precedent was wrong and that they are legally innocent of the crime of conviction.

Opinion summary

Etalia.ai summary of the majority opinion

The case asked whether a federal prisoner who already used a § 2255 motion can use the saving clause in § 2255(e) to file a § 2241 habeas petition based on a later Supreme Court decision interpreting the criminal statute more favorably. Justice Thomas, writing for the Court, held that he cannot. The Court said § 2255 was created to move federal prisoners’ collateral attacks to the sentencing court, and AEDPA then limited second or successive § 2255 motions to narrow grounds. The saving clause preserves § 2241 only when it is impossible or impracticable to seek relief in the sentencing court, not when AEDPA bars a statutory claim. The Court also rejected the petitioner’s Suspension Clause and other constitutional arguments, reasoning that this kind of statutory-interpretation claim was not cognizable in habeas at the founding and that Congress may limit successive collateral review.

Dissent summary

Etalia.ai summary of the dissenting opinions

Justice Sotomayor, joined by Justice Kagan, dissented. They argued that the majority’s reading leaves an actually innocent prisoner forever barred from relief just because he previously sought postconviction review. In their view, § 2255 was meant to provide a remedy equivalent to habeas, and the saving clause should allow habeas when § 2255 is inadequate to test a claim that was cognizable in pre-AEDPA habeas. Justice Jackson also dissented, arguing that the majority wrongly treated the saving clause as nearly meaningless and that a prisoner should be able to bring a newly available legal innocence claim when Congress has not clearly foreclosed it. She emphasized the constitutional concerns with permanently blocking a potentially innocent person from any meaningful court review.

Opinion written by Justice Thomas

Decided 22 Jun 2023 · Official report

599us1r42_2b35.pdfOpen in a new tab

Oral argument transcript

Argued 1 Nov 2022

21-857_iie0.pdfOpen in a new tab