Samia v. United States

Questions presented

SCOTUS records, cert granted 13 Dec 2022

Whether admitting a codefendant's redacted out-of-court confession that immediately inculpates a defendant based on the surrounding context violates the defendant's rights under the Confrontation Clause of the Sixth Amendment.

Opinion summary

Etalia.ai summary of the majority opinion

The case asked whether the Confrontation Clause bars admitting a nontestifying codefendant’s confession at a joint trial when the confession has been redacted to avoid naming the defendant and the jury is told to use it only against the confessor. The Court held that it does not. Writing for the Court, Justice Thomas said Stillwell’s Mirandized confession was testimonial, but under historical practice and the Court’s precedents a confession that does not directly inculpate the defendant, together with a proper limiting instruction, may be admitted. The Court distinguished Bruton, which involved a confession naming the defendant, and Gray, which involved an obvious redaction such as a blank or the word deleted. It said this confession used neutral references like “other person,” was not obviously redacted, and did not require the Court to police indirect inferences drawn from other evidence. The Court also said expanding Bruton as Samia urged would be inconsistent with precedent and would unnecessarily burden joint trials. The judgment was affirmed.

Dissent summary

Etalia.ai summary of the dissenting opinions

Justice Kagan, joined by Justice Sotomayor and Justice Jackson, argued that the Court let the government do indirectly what Bruton and Gray forbid directly. In the dissent’s view, if a confession naming a codefendant or using an obvious blank cannot be admitted, then replacing the name with a neutral phrase like “a woman” should not make a constitutional difference when jurors will still understand who is meant. The dissent said the majority elevated form over substance and allowed an end-run around the Confrontation Clause. Justice Jackson also filed a separate dissent, though the text provided only indicates that it was filed and does not set out its full reasoning.

Opinion written by Justice Thomas

Decided 23 Jun 2023 · Official report

599us1r46_dc8f.pdfOpen in a new tab

Oral argument transcript

Argued 29 Mar 2023

22-196_8kj4.pdfOpen in a new tab