Questions presented
SCOTUS records, cert granted 13 Jan 2023
The False Claims Act protects government programs from fraud by, inter alia, imposing civil liability on anybody who knowingly presents false claims for payment to the government or makes false statements that are material to such claims. 31 U.S.C. § 3729(a). The statute defines "knowingly" to include acting with: (1) actual knowledge; (2) deliberate ignorance; or (3) reckless disregard of the falsity of information. See id. § 3729(b)(l)(A). The question presented is: Whether and when a defendant's contemporaneous subjective understanding or beliefs about the lawfulness of its conduct are relevant to whether it "knowingly" violated the False Claims Act.
Opinion summary
Etalia.ai summary of the majority opinion
The case concerned False Claims Act suits against SuperValu and Safeway over pharmacy reimbursements billed to Medicare and Medicaid. Petitioners said the companies reported higher retail prices instead of discounted prices that should have been their “usual and customary” prices, and that the companies believed the claims were inaccurate. The lower courts granted summary judgment for the companies on scienter, and the Seventh Circuit relied on an objective reasonableness approach drawn from Safeco. Justice Thomas, writing for a unanimous Court, rejected that approach. The Court held that the FCA’s scienter requirement turns on a defendant’s knowledge and subjective beliefs, not on whether an objectively reasonable interpretation could support the claim. Facial ambiguity in the billing phrase did not by itself defeat scienter, and the companies’ argument based on common-law fraud failed because the alleged statements were not pure misrepresentations of law but statements implying facts about their prices. The Court vacated and remanded.
Opinion written by Justice Thomas
Decided 1 Jun 2023 · Official report
Oral argument transcript
Argued 18 Apr 2023