Cases of the 1856 term
64 cases, in order of decision.
Coggeshall v. Hartshorn
154 U.S. 533 · Decided 12 Dec 1856Coggeshall v. Hartshorn was a case heard by the United States Supreme Court in 1856.
Romelius L. Baker and Jacob Henrici, Trustees of the Harmony Society of Beaver County, Pennsylvania, and Others, Appellants, v. Joshua Nachtrieb
60 U.S. 126 · Decided 16 Dec 1856 · Justice CampbellIn the case of Romelius L. Baker and Jacob Henrici, Trustees of the Harmony Society of Beaver County, Pennsylvania, and others v. Joshua Nachtrieb, the Supreme Court was asked to decide whether a deed executed by an ind…
The United States, Plaintiffs in Error, v. George N. Stewart
60 U.S. 79 · Decided 16 Dec 1856 · Justice CurtisIn the United States Supreme Court case of The United States v. George N. Stewart, the plaintiff argued that a certain piece of land in California was part of a Mexican grant and thus belonged to them as it had been acq…
The United States, Plaintiff in Error, v. Charles Le Baron
60 U.S. 73 · Decided 16 Dec 1856 · Justice CurtisIn the United States Supreme Court case of The United States, Plaintiff in Error v. Charles Le Baron, the court was asked to decide whether a federal statute that prohibited citizens from selling or trading with Native…
The United States, Appellants, v. the Brig Neurea, Her Tackle, &c., William Kohler, Claimant
60 U.S. 92 · Decided 17 Dec 1856 · Justice GrierThe United States brought an appeal against William Kohler, the claimant of The Brig Neurea.
Elizabeth Moore, Complainant and Appellant, v. Ray Greene and Benjamin W. Hawkins
60 U.S. 69 · Decided 24 Dec 1856 · Justice McLeanElizabeth Moore brought a case against Ray Greene and Benjamin W. Hawkins in the Supreme Court of Mississippi.
Obadiah H. Platt, Plaintiff in Error, v. Chauncey Jerome
60 U.S. 384 · Decided 24 Dec 1856 · Justice NelsonObadiah H. Platt brought a case against Chauncey Jerome in the Supreme Court of Errors of Connecticut, alleging that he had been defrauded by Jerome in an 1851 contract for the sale and delivery of clocks.
Reuben L. Long, John S. Penrise, and Amelia Penrise, His Wife, and Alice Penrise, by Hfr Guardian, John S. Penrise, Complainants and Appellants, v. John O'Fallon
60 U.S. 116 · Decided 29 Dec 1856 · Justice CampbellReuben L. Long, John S. Penrise, Amelia Penrise (his wife), and Alice Penrise (by her guardian) were the complainants and appellants in this case against John O'Fallon.
Sebastian Willot, John Mcdonald, and Joseph Hunn, Plaintiffs in Error, v. John F. A. Sandford
60 U.S. 79 · Decided 29 Dec 1856 · Justice CatronIn the case of Sebastian Willot, John McDonald, and Joseph Hunn v. John F. A. Sandford, the plaintiffs in error argued that they were illegally held as slaves by Sandford while living in Illinois - a free state at the t…
William Thomas, Southworth Barnes, Nathaniel Russell, and Others, Owners of the Barque Laura, Appellants, v. James W. Osborn
60 U.S. 22 · Decided 29 Dec 1856 · Justice CurtisThis Supreme Court case involved the owners of a barque named Laura, who appealed to the court after James W. Osborn had taken possession of their vessel and refused to return it.
C. C. Lathrop, Plaintiff in Error, v. Charles Judson
60 U.S. 66 · Decided 7 Jan 1857 · Justice McLeanIn the case of C.C. Lathrop v Charles Judson, the plaintiff in error (Lathrop) argued that he had a right to recover damages for an injury caused by the defendant's negligence.
E. G. Rogers and L. F. Rogers, Merchants and Copartners, Doing Business Under the Name and Style of E. G. Rogers & Co., Part Owners of the Cargo of the Schooner Ella; Pooley, Nicoll, & Co., Owners of the Said Schooner Ella; J. R. Brooks and F. G. Randolph, Merchants and Copartners, Doing Business Under the Name and Style of Brooks & Randolph, and Thomas Sullivan, Trading Under the Name of John Hurley & Co., Part Owners of the Cargo of the Schooner Ella, Appellants, v. the Steamer St. Charles, James L. Day, Adam Wolf, John Geddes, John Grant, Roger A. Heirne, and Robert Geddes, Claimants.
60 U.S. 108 · Decided 7 Jan 1857 · Justice NelsonIn the case of E. G. Rogers and L. F. Rogers, Merchants and Copartners, doing business under the name and style of E. G. Rogers & Co., Pooley, Nicoll & Co., owners of the schooner Ella; J R Brooks and F G Randolph, merc…
William H. Seymour and Layton S. Morgan, Plaintiffs in Error, v. Cyrus H. Mccormick
60 U.S. 96 · Decided 7 Jan 1857 · Justice NelsonIn the case of William H. Seymour and Layton S. Morgan v. Cyrus H. McCormick, the plaintiffs argued that a patent held by McCormick for an improved reaping machine was invalid because it infringed on earlier patents hel…
Robert J. Vandewater, Appellant, v. Edward Mills, Claimant of the Steamship Yankee Blade, Her Tackle, &c
60 U.S. 82 · Decided 7 Jan 1857 · Justice GrierIn Robert J. Vandewater v. Edward Mills, the Supreme Court was asked to decide who had a valid claim of ownership over the steamship Yankee Blade and its associated tackle.
Ex Parte, in the Matter of David A. Secombe
60 U.S. 9 · Decided 12 Jan 1857 · Justice TaneyIn Ex Parte In the Matter of David A. Secombe, a case heard before the United States Supreme Court in 1856, an appeal was made by David A. Secombe from a decision of the Circuit Court for Florida which had denied his pe…
James Stevens, Plaintiff in Error, v. Royal Gladding and Isaac T. Proud, Trading Under the Name and Firm of Gladding & Proud Defendants
60 U.S. 64 · Decided 12 Jan 1857 · Justice McLeanThis case was between James Stevens, the plaintiff in error, and Royal Gladding and Isaac T. Proud who were trading under the name of Gladding & Proud as defendants.
James H. Ure, Claimant of the Steamer Gipsey, Appellant, v. James M. Coffman and Cyrus Coffman, Owners of Flat-Boat and Cargo
60 U.S. 56 · Decided 12 Jan 1857 · Justice WayneThis Supreme Court case involved James H. Ure, the claimant of the steamer Gipsey, and James M. Coffman and Cyrus Coffman, owners of a flat-boat and cargo.
Jean Louis Prevost, Plaintiff in Error, v. Charles E. Greneaux, Treasurer of the State of Louisiana
60 U.S. 1 · Decided 13 Jan 1857 · Justice TaneyIn the case of Jean Louis Prevost v. Charles E. Greneau, Treasurer of the State of Louisiana, Prevost argued that he was entitled to a refund from taxes paid on certain property in New Orleans because it had been illega…
Wesley Williams, Garnishee of Edward F. Mahone, Plaintiff in Error, v. Hill, Mclane, & Co
60 U.S. 246 · Decided 13 Jan 1857 · Justice CampbellIn the case of Wesley Williams, Garnishee of Edward F. Mahone, Plaintiff in Error v. Hill, McLane & Co., the Supreme Court was asked to determine whether a garnishment order issued by a state court could be enforced aga…
Pierre Felix Coiron and Marie J. T. Coiron, a Minor, by Her Next Friend, Pierre Felix Coiron, Appellants, v. Laurent Millaudon, Edward Shiff, Syndics, &c., of Alexander Lesseps, et al.
60 U.S. 113 · Decided 15 Jan 1857 · Justice NelsonIn the case of Pierre Felix Coiron and Marie J.T. Coiron v Laurent Millaudon, Edward Shiff, Syndics &c., of Alexander Lesseps et al., a dispute arose between two parties over an unpaid debt owed by one party to another.
Benjamin F. Morgan, Plaintiff in Error, v. Alfred G. Curtenius and John L. Griswold
60 U.S. 8 · Decided 15 Jan 1857 · Justice TaneyThis Supreme Court case involved Benjamin F. Morgan, the plaintiff in error, and Alfred G. Curtenius and John L. Griswold, defendants in error.
Burr H. Betts, Appellant, v. John H. Lewis, and Mary M. F. Lewis, His Wife
60 U.S. 72 · Decided 20 Jan 1857 · Justice CurtisIn the case of Burr H. Betts v. John H. Lewis and Mary M. F. Lewis, his wife, the Supreme Court was asked to determine whether a deed from one party to another was valid or not when it had been signed by only one of two…
E.J. Dupont de Nemours & Co., Libellants and Appellants, v. John Vance et al., Claimants of the Brig Ann Elizabeth
60 U.S. 162 · Decided 20 Jan 1857 · Justice CurtisIn the case of E.J. DuPont de Nemours & Co., Libellants and Appellants, v. John Vance et al., Claimants of the Brig Ann Elizabeth, a dispute arose between two parties regarding ownership rights to a brig named Ann Eliza…
James Meegan, Plaintiff in Error, v. Jeremiah T. Boyle
60 U.S. 130 · Decided 20 Jan 1857 · Justice McLeanJames Meegan brought a case against Jeremiah T. Boyle in the Supreme Court of the United States.
William A. Shaffer, Plaintiff in Error, v. James A. Scudday
60 U.S. 16 · Decided 22 Jan 1857 · Justice TaneyIn the case of William A. Shaffer v. James A. Scudday, the Supreme Court was asked to decide whether a contract between two parties should be enforced even if it had been made under false pretenses and with fraudulent i…
John Bell, Plaintiff in Error, v. Columbus C. Hearne, Samuel R. Hearne, and Samuel H.dockery
60 U.S. 252 · Decided 27 Jan 1857 · Justice CampbellJohn Bell, plaintiff in error, brought a case against Columbus C. Hearne, Samuel R. Hearne and Samuel H. Dockery for the recovery of certain slaves that were allegedly wrongfully taken from him by the defendants.
John Brown, Plaintiff in Error, v. Duchesne
60 U.S. 183 · Decided 27 Jan 1857 · Justice TaneyJohn Brown, plaintiff in error, brought a case against Duchesne before the United States Supreme Court.
Terence Cousin, Plaintiff in Error, v. Fanny Labatut, Widow and Testamentary Executrix, Jules A. Blanc, Co-Executor, and Others, Legal Representatives of Evariste Blanc
60 U.S. 202 · Decided 27 Jan 1857 · Justice CatronTerence Cousin, the plaintiff in error, brought a case against Fanny Labatut, widow and testamentary executrix of Evariste Blanc; Jules A. Blanc, co-executor; and other legal representatives of Evariste Blanc.
Isaac Hartshorn and Daniel Hayward, Plaintiffs in Error v. Horace H. Day
60 U.S. 211 · Decided 27 Jan 1857 · Justice NelsonIsaac Hartshorn and Daniel Hayward, plaintiffs in error, brought a case against Horace H. Day for the wrongful possession of certain real estate located in New York State.
The New York and Virginia Steamship Company, Owners of the Steamer Roanoke, Appellants, v. Ezra Calderwood, Thomas C. Bartlett, Dexter Carleton, Joshua Norwood, Philander Carleton, Enos Cooper, and Seth Cooper, Libellants
60 U.S. 241 · Decided 27 Jan 1857 · Justice CampbellThe New York and Virginia Steamship Company, owners of the steamer Roanoke, appealed a case in which Ezra Calderwood, Thomas C. Bartlett, Dexter Carleton, Joshua Norwood, Philander Carleton Enos Cooper and Seth Cooper h…
The Claimants and Owners of the Steamer Virginia, Appellants, v. Michael W. West, William T. Bell, Albert R. Heath, and James J. Edwards, Partners, Under the Firm of Heath & Edwards; Thomas C. Bunting and Lecato, Partners, Under the Firm of Bunting & Lecato, and John M. Henderson
60 U.S. 182 · Decided 27 Jan 1857 · Justice TaneyThe Supreme Court case of The Claimants and Owners of the Steamer Virginia v. Michael W. West, William T. Bell, Albert R. Heath, James J. Edwards, Thomas C Bunting and Lecato (partners under the firm of Bunting & Lecato…
William E. Post and Others, Claimants of a Portion of the Cargo of the Ship Richmond, Appellants, v. John H. Jones and Others, Libellants
60 U.S. 150 · Decided 28 Jan 1857 · Justice GrierIn the case of William E. Post and Others, Claimants of a Portion of the Cargo of the Ship Richmond v. John H. Jones and Others, Libellants, two parties were in dispute over ownership rights to cargo from a ship called…
Moses C. Mordecai, Isaac E. Hertz, Joseph A. Enslow, and Isaac R. Mordecai, Carrying on Business Under the Name, Style, and Firm, of Mordecai & Co., Libellants and Appellants, v. W. & N. Lindsay, Owners of the Schooner Mary Eddy, Her T
60 U.S. 199 · Decided 2 Feb 1857 · Justice WayneThis Supreme Court case involves the libellants and appellants, Moses C. Mordecai, Isaac E. Hertz, Joseph A. Enslow, and Isaac R. Mordecai carrying on business under the name of Mordecai & Co., versus W & N Lindsay owne…
Frederick Schuchardt and Frederick C. Gebbard, Libellants and Appellants, v. Winthrop S. Babbidge and Others, Claimants of Half of the Proceeds of the Ship Angelique
60 U.S. 239 · Decided 2 Feb 1857 · Justice NelsonThis Supreme Court case involved the dispute between Frederick Schuchardt and Frederick Gebbard, who were libellants and appellants, and Winthrop S. Babbidge and others, who were claimants of half of the proceeds from a…
Horatio N. Slater, Plaintiff in Error, v. Charles Emerson
60 U.S. 224 · Decided 10 Feb 1857 · Justice McLeanIn the case of Horatio N. Slater v. Charles Emerson, the plaintiff in error argued that he was entitled to a judgment against Emerson for damages resulting from an alleged breach of contract between them.
The Commercial Mutual Marine Insurance Company, Appellants, v. the Union Mutual Insurance Company of New York
60 U.S. 318 · Decided 17 Feb 1857 · Justice CurtisIn the case of The Commercial Mutual Marine Insurance Company, Appellants v. The Union Mutual Insurance Company of New York, the Supreme Court was tasked with deciding whether a policy issued by one insurance company to…
Felicite Fletcher Hipp, and Maria Antonio Fletcher Hipp, Aliens, and Residing, the Former in Vera Cruz, Mexico, the Latter in the City of Madrid, Spain, for Themselves and on Behalf and for the Use of Augustin Cuesta, Javiera Cuesta, and Felicitas Cuesta, Aliens, the Forced Heirs of Adelaide Fletcher Hipp, Deceased, v. Celine Babin, Widow of Ursin Joly, and Others
60 U.S. 271 · Decided 17 Feb 1857 · Justice CampbellIn the case of Felicite Fletcher Hipp and Maria Antonio Fletcher Hipp, two aliens residing in Vera Cruz, Mexico and Madrid, Spain respectively, they were suing on behalf of Augustin Cuesta, Javiera Cuesta and Felicitas…
Archibald Babcock, Appellant, v. Edward Wyman
60 U.S. 289 · Decided 18 Feb 1857 · Justice McLeanIn the case of Archibald Babcock, Appellant v. Edward Wyman, the Supreme Court was asked to decide whether a contract between two parties could be enforced when it had been made without consideration and in violation of…
Thomas Richardson, Plaintiff in Error, v. the City of Boston
60 U.S. 263 · Decided 18 Feb 1857 · Justice GrierThomas Richardson, plaintiff in error, brought a case against the City of Boston.
John D. Wolfe, Executor, and Maria D. L. Ronalds, Executrix, of Thomas A. Ronalds, Deceased, Appellants, v. John H. Lewis
60 U.S. 280 · Decided 18 Feb 1857 · Justice McLeanJohn D. Wolfe, executor, and Maria D. L. Ronalds, executrix of Thomas A. Ronalds' estate (the appellants) brought a case against John H Lewis (the respondent).
Edward Field, Plaintiff in Error, v. Pardon G. Seabury et al.
60 U.S. 323 · Decided 19 Feb 1857 · Justice WayneEdward Field brought a case against Pardon G. Seabury and others in the United States Supreme Court.
Edward Field, Plaintiff in Error, v. Pardon G. Seabury et al.
60 U.S. 333 · Decided 19 Feb 1857 · Justice WayneEdward Field brought a case before the Supreme Court against Pardon G. Seabury and others, claiming that he had been wrongfully deprived of his right to vote in an election for members of Congress in New York.
Patrick Burke, Plaintiff in Error, v. William H. Gaines and Wife, et al.
60 U.S. 388 · Decided 23 Feb 1857 · Justice TaneyPatrick Burke brought a case against William H. Gaines and his wife, as well as other defendants, to the Supreme Court of the United States.
George Bulkley, Plaintiff in Error, v. Christian Honold
60 U.S. 390 · Decided 27 Feb 1857 · Justice CurtisGeorge Bulkley, plaintiff in error, brought a case against Christian Honold to the Supreme Court.
Oliver and Daniel R. Garrison, Appellants, v. the Memphis Insurance Company
60 U.S. 312 · Decided 27 Feb 1857 · Justice CampbellIn Oliver and Daniel R. Garrison v. The Memphis Insurance Company, the appellants argued that they had a valid policy with the insurance company for their steamboat, which was destroyed by fire in 1851.
Lathrop L. Sturgis, Plaintiff in Error, v. Christian Honold
60 U.S. 393 · Decided 27 Feb 1857 · Justice CurtisIn the case of Lathrop L. Sturgis v. Christian Honold, Sturgis brought a suit against Honold for damages resulting from an alleged breach of contract between them.
Samuel F. Pratt, Pascal P. Pratt, and Edward P. Beals, Claimants of the Steamboat Sultana, Appellants, v. Charles M. Reed, Libellant
60 U.S. 359 · Decided 27 Feb 1857 · Justice NelsonIn the case of Samuel F. Pratt, Pascal P. Pratt, and Edward P. Beals v Charles M. Reed, the Supreme Court was asked to determine whether a steamboat called Sultana had been properly registered with the Collector of Cust…
Daniel Tod, Daniel P. Rhodes, Robert C. Yates, and James Ford, Libellants and Appellants, v. Samuel F. Pratt and Edward P. Beals, Claimants of Steamboat Sultana, Her Engine, Boiler, &c
60 U.S. 362 · Decided 27 Feb 1857 · Justice NelsonIn the case of Daniel Tod, Daniel P. Rhodes, Robert C. Yates and James Ford v Samuel F. Pratt and Edward P. Beals, the libellants sought to recover damages for injuries they sustained when their steamboat Sultana explod…
The United States, Plaintiffs, v. the City Bank of Columbus
60 U.S. 385 · Decided 27 Feb 1857 · Justice DanielIn The United States v. The City Bank of Columbus, the Supreme Court was asked to decide whether a state-chartered bank could be sued in federal court for debts it owed under its charter.
Josiah Walton, Administrator of Priscilla Cotton, et al., Complainants and Plaintiffs in Error, v. Allen Cotton, Noah Cotton, and William E. Jones
60 U.S. 355 · Decided 27 Feb 1857 · Justice McLeanIn the case of Josiah Walton, Administrator of Priscilla Cotton et al. v Allen Cotton, Noah Cotton and William E. Jones, the Supreme Court was tasked with determining whether a deed executed by Priscilla Cotton in 1841…
Charles Ballance, Plaintiff in Error, v. Adolph Papin, Henry Papin, and Mary Atchison
60 U.S. 342 · Decided 5 Mar 1857 · Justice CatronCharles Ballance brought a case to the Supreme Court against Adolph Papin, Henry Papin, and Mary Atchison.
Albert Ballard, Charles Chadbourne, Eliphalet Gilman, and Henry W. Heird, Trading Under the Firm of Ballard, Chadbourne, & Co., v. Philip F. Thomas, Collector
60 U.S. 382 · Decided 5 Mar 1857 · Justice NelsonIn Ballard, Chadbourne & Co. v. Philip F. Thomas, the Supreme Court of the United States considered a dispute between two parties over an alleged violation of federal revenue laws in 1853 and 1854 by Ballard, Chadbourne…
Roswell Beebe et al., Appellants, v. William Russell
60 U.S. 283 · Decided 5 Mar 1857 · Justice WayneIn the case of Roswell Beebe et al. v. William Russell, the appellants argued that a contract between them and Russell was invalid due to fraud on his part.
William F. Bryan and Rudolphus Rouse, Plaintiffs in Error, v. Robert Forsyth
60 U.S. 334 · Decided 5 Mar 1857 · Justice CatronWilliam F. Bryan and Rudolphus Rouse brought a case against Robert Forsyth to the United States Supreme Court in 1856.
William Byers, Appellant, v. Francis Surget
60 U.S. 303 · Decided 5 Mar 1857 · Justice DanielIn the case of William Byers v. Francis Surget, Byers appealed a decision from the Circuit Court of Louisiana that granted Surget title to certain land in dispute between them.
Terence Farrelly, Edward O. Morton, et al., Heirs and Representatives of Frederic Notribe, Appellants, v. William W. Woodfolk
60 U.S. 288 · Decided 5 Mar 1857 · Justice WayneIn Terence Farrely, Edward O. Morton, et al., Heirs and Representatives of Frederic Notribe v. William W. Woodfolk, the appellants were heirs and representatives of a deceased man named Frederic Notribe who had owned la…
Joseph Fellows, Survivor of Robert Kendle, Plaintiff in Error, v. Susan Blacksmith and Ely S. Parker, Administrators of John Blacksmith, Deceased
60 U.S. 366 · Decided 5 Mar 1857 · Justice NelsonJoseph Fellows, survivor of Robert Kendle, brought a case against Susan Blacksmith and Ely S. Parker, administrators of John Blacksmith who had passed away.
John Mccullough and Cyrus D. Culbertson, Plaintiffs in Error, v. Gurnsey Y. Roots and Erastus P. Coe
60 U.S. 349 · Decided 5 Mar 1857 · Justice CampbellJohn McCullough and Cyrus D. Culbertson were the plaintiffs in error in a Supreme Court case against Gurnsey Y. Roots and Erastus P. Coe, which was decided by the court on April 7th 1856.
Margaret Mcrea and Bracy Mcrea, Administrators of John D. Bracy, Appellants, v. the Branch of the Bank of the State of Alabama at Mobile
60 U.S. 376 · Decided 5 Mar 1857 · Justice CurtisIn Margaret McRea and Bracy McRea, Administrators of John D. Bracy v. The Branch of the Bank of the State of Alabama at Mobile, the Supreme Court was asked to decide whether a state bank could be held liable for failing…
The Michigan Central Railroad Company, Plaintiffs in Error. v. the Michigan Southern Railroad Company et al.
60 U.S. 378 · Decided 5 Mar 1857 · Justice GrierThe Michigan Central Railroad Company brought a case against the Michigan Southern Railroad Company and others.
Enoch C. Roberts, Plaintiff in Error, v. James M. Cooper
60 U.S. 373 · Decided 5 Mar 1857 · Justice WayneThis Supreme Court case involved Enoch C. Roberts, the plaintiff in error, and James M. Cooper.
The United States, Appellants, v. Domingo and Vicente Peralta
60 U.S. 343 · Decided 5 Mar 1857 · Justice GrierIn the United States Supreme Court case of The United States v. Domingo and Vicente Peralta, the court was asked to decide whether two brothers had a valid claim to land in California that they inherited from their fath…
The United States, Appellants, v. Thomas W. Sutherland, Guardian of Victoria, Isabel, Miguel, and Helina, Minor Children of Miguel de Pedrorena, Deceased
60 U.S. 363 · Decided 5 Mar 1857 · Justice GrierIn the United States Supreme Court case of The United States v. Thomas W. Sutherland, Guardian of Victoria, Isabel, Miguel and Helina, Minor Children of Miguel de Pedrorena Deceased, the court was asked to decide whethe…
Dred Scott, Plaintiff in Error, v. John F. A. Sandford
60 U.S. 393 · Decided 6 Mar 1857 · Justice TaneyDred Scott was an enslaved African American man who sued for his freedom in the Supreme Court case of Dred Scott v. John F. A. Sandford in 1856.