Andy Warhol Foundation for the Visual Arts v. Goldsmith

Questions presented

SCOTUS records, cert granted 28 Mar 2022

This Court has repeatedly made clear that a work of art is "transformative" for purposes of fair use under the Copyright Act if it conveys a different "meaning or message" from its source material. Campbell v. Acuff-Rose Music, Inc., 510 U.S. 569, 579 (1994); Google LLC v. Oracle Am., Inc., 141 8. Ct. 1183, 1202 (2021). In the decision below, the Second Circuit nonetheless held that a court is in fact forbidden from trying to "ascertain the intent behind or meaning of the works at issue." App. 22a-23a. Instead, the court concluded that even where a new work indisputably conveys a distinct meaning or message, the work is not transformative if it "recognizably deriv[es] from, and retain[s] the essential elements of, its source material." Id. at 24a. The question presented is: Whether a work of art is "transformative" when it conveys a different meaning or message from its source material (as this Court, the Ninth Circuit, and other courts of appeals have held), or whether a court is forbidden from considering the meaning of the accused work where it "recognizably deriv[es] from" its source material (as the Second Circuit has held).

Opinion summary

Etalia.ai summary of the majority opinion

The dispute was whether Andy Warhol Foundation’s commercial license of Orange Prince to Condé Nast infringed Lynn Goldsmith’s copyright in her 1981 Prince photograph, or instead qualified as fair use. Writing for the Court, Justice Sotomayor held that the first fair use factor, the purpose and character of the use, favored Goldsmith. The Court said the relevant use was AWF’s 2016 licensing of Orange Prince to illustrate a magazine story about Prince, and that this use shared substantially the same purpose as Goldsmith’s photo because both were portraits used in magazines about Prince. The Court also emphasized that AWF’s use was commercial. It rejected the idea that adding new expression or a different message automatically makes a use transformative enough for fair use, because that would undermine the copyright owner’s right to prepare derivative works. On that narrow question, the Court affirmed the court of appeals.

Dissent summary

Etalia.ai summary of the dissenting opinions

Justice Kagan filed a dissenting opinion, in which Chief Justice Roberts joined. The dissent argued that Warhol’s work was transformative because it conveyed a different meaning and served a different purpose from Goldsmith’s photograph, and that the majority gave too much weight to the commercial license and too little to Warhol’s artistic changes. It also warned that the Court’s approach would improperly narrow fair use for art and other derivative works by focusing on the licensing transaction rather than the work’s expressive differences.

Opinion written by Justice Sotomayor

Decided 18 May 2023 · Official report

598us2r23_c0n2.pdfOpen in a new tab

Oral argument transcript

Argued 12 Oct 2022

21-869_986b.pdfOpen in a new tab