Questions presented
SCOTUS records, cert granted 28 Mar 2022
Proposition 12 bans the sale of pork in California unless the sow from which it derived was housed with space allowances that almost no farms satisfy (for good reason). Californians account for 13% of the Nation's pork consumption, but raise hardly any pigs. The massive costs of complying with Proposition 12 fall almost exclusively on out-of-state farmers. And because a single pig is processed into cuts that are sold nationwide in response to demand, those costs will be passed on to consumers everywhere, in countless transactions having nothing to do with California. The Ninth Circuit acknowledged that petitioners plausibly allege that Proposition 12 has "dramatic upstream effects," requires "pervasive changes to the pork production industry nationwide," and imposes costs that "mostly fall on non-California transactions." Nevertheless- in conflict with other circuits and contrary to the views of amici the United States, 20 States, and business groups-it held that petitioners failed to plead a dormant Commerce Clause violation. In doing so, it brushed aside this Court's decisions holding that laws with significant extraterritorial effects violate our federalist scheme, and failed to engage in meaningful balancing under Pike v. Bruce Church, Inc. The questions presented are: Whether allegations that a state law has dramatic economic effects largely outside of the state and requires pervasive changes to an integrated nationwide industry state a violation of the dormant Commerce Clause, or whether the extraterritoriality principle described in this Court's decisions is now a dead letter. Whether such allegations, concerning a law that is based solely on preferences regarding out-of-state housing of farm animals, state a Pike claim.
Opinion summary
Etalia.ai summary of the majority opinion
The case challenged California Proposition 12, which bars the in-state sale of whole pork meat from breeding pigs confined in a way that prevents them from lying down, standing up, fully extending their limbs, or turning around freely. Pork producers argued that the law violated the dormant Commerce Clause because it burdened interstate commerce and had unconstitutional extraterritorial effects. Writing for the Court in part, Justice Gorsuch said the law does not purposefully discriminate against out-of-state economic interests, so the core antidiscrimination principle was not implicated. The Court rejected the claimed “extraterritoriality” rule as having no basis in the cited precedents, and it read Pike v. Bruce Church as not supporting invalidation here. The Court also concluded that, even on petitioners’ own theory, the complaint did not plausibly allege a substantial burden on interstate commerce. The judgment of the Ninth Circuit was affirmed.
Dissent summary
Etalia.ai summary of the dissenting opinions
Chief Justice Roberts, joined by Justices Alito, Kavanaugh, and Jackson, concurred in part and dissented in part. He said the complaint should have been treated as adequately alleging a substantial burden on interstate commerce, and that the case should have been remanded for the lower court to apply Pike balancing. Justice Kavanaugh also concurred in part and dissented in part. He agreed that Pike balancing can be done, but would have held that the complaint plausibly alleged a substantial burden and that the burdens and benefits of Proposition 12 should be weighed by the lower court.
Opinion written by Justice Gorsuch
Decided 11 May 2023 · Official report
Oral argument transcript
Argued 11 Oct 2022