Questions presented
SCOTUS records, cert granted 24 Jan 2022
Petitioners Michael and Chantell Sackett own a vacant lot in a mostly built-out residential subdivision near Priest Lake, Idaho. The lot has no surface water connection to any body of water. In April, 2007, with local permits in hand, the Sacketts began building a family home. But later that year, Respondent Environmental Protection Agency sent them an administrative compliance order determining that their home construction violated the Clean Water Act because their lot contains wetlands that qualify as regulated "navigable waters." In Rapanos v. United States, 54 7 U.S. 715 (2006), the Court held that the Clean Water Act does not regulate all wetlands, but no opinion explaining why that is so garnered a majority of the Court. A plurality opinion authored by Justice Scalia and joined by three other Justices argued that only those wetlands that have a continuous surface water connection to regulated waters may themselves be regulated. A concurring opinion by Justice Kennedy advanced a different and much broader test, allowing for regulation of wetlands regardless of any surface connection, so long as the wetlands bear an (undefined) "significant nexus" with traditional navigable waters. Below, the Ninth Circuit employed Justice Kennedy's "significant nexus" test to uphold EPA's authority over the Sacketts' homesite. The question presented is: Should Rapanos be revisited to adopt the plurality's test for wetlands jurisdiction under the Clean Water Act?
Opinion summary
Etalia.ai summary of the majority opinion
The dispute was whether wetlands on the Sacketts’ property were covered by the Clean Water Act because they were near a ditch, creek, and lake. The Court held that the Act reaches only relatively permanent bodies of water such as streams, oceans, rivers, and lakes, and adjacent wetlands only when they have a continuous surface connection to such waters so that it is hard to tell where the water ends and the wetland begins. The Court rejected the EPA’s broader significant-nexus approach, saying it gave the agencies too much power and was hard to square with the statute’s text and structure. Applying that reading, the Court concluded the Act’s jurisdiction is limited to wetlands that are, as a practical matter, indistinguishable from covered waters.
Opinion written by Justice Alito
Decided 25 May 2023 · Official report
Oral argument transcript
Argued 3 Oct 2022