Questions presented
SCOTUS records, cert granted 28 Mar 2022
In Simmons v. South Carolina, 512 U.S. 154 (1994), this Court held that in cases where a capital defendant's future dangerousness is at issue, due process entitles the defendant to inform the jury that he will be ineligible for parole if not sentenced to death. For many years thereafter, the Arizona Supreme Court refused to apply Simmons. In Lynch v. Arizona, 578 U.S. 613 (2016) (per curiam), this Court summarily reversed the Arizona Supreme Court's misapplication of Simmons and confirmed that the Simmons rule applies in Arizona. This petition is brought by a capital defendant in Arizona whose conviction became final after Simmons but before Lynch. He was sentenced to death after the trial judge repeatedly denied him his right under Simmons to inform the jury that he was parole-ineligible. After this Court in Lynch applied Simmons to Arizona, he sought postconviction relief in state court seeking the relief that Simmons and Lynch require. The Arizona Supreme Court denied his claim. Although Arizona provides a forum for federal constitutional claims on collateral review, and although the Arizona Supreme Court recognized that Lynch "was dictated by" Simmons, the court concluded that the rule of Lynch should not apply to cases pending on collateral review. This petition presents the question whether this Court's decision in Lynch applied a settled rule of federal law that must be applied to cases pending on collateral review in Arizona.
Opinion summary
Etalia.ai summary of the majority opinion
Justice Sotomayor wrote that Arizona could not use its postconviction rule to bar Cruz from raising his Simmons claim after this Court’s decision in Lynch. Cruz had argued at trial, on direct appeal, and later in state postconviction proceedings that the jury should have been told that a life sentence meant no parole. The Arizona Supreme Court said Lynch was not a “significant change in the law,” but this Court held that was an exceptionally novel and unforeseeable reading of the rule. Lynch had overruled binding Arizona precedent and changed how Simmons operated in Arizona courts, so the state procedural ruling was not an adequate ground to block federal review. The judgment was vacated and the case remanded.
Dissent summary
Etalia.ai summary of the dissenting opinions
Justice Barrett dissented, joined by Justices Thomas, Alito, and Gorsuch. She argued that the Court should respect Arizona’s interpretation of its own procedural rule unless the state court’s ruling was so disingenuous that it revealed hostility to federal rights. In her view, Arizona confronted a new question about whether a decision that reaffirmed existing law but corrected an erroneous application of it counted as a “significant change in the law.” She said the Arizona Supreme Court’s distinction between a change in law and a change in application was reasonably consistent with its precedent, not an unforeseeable departure. She also warned that the Court was effectively reinterpreting state law under the guise of deciding adequacy.
Opinion written by Justice Sotomayor
Decided 22 Feb 2023 · Official report
Oral argument transcript
Argued 1 Nov 2022