Arkansas v. Delaware

Opinion summary

Etalia.ai summary of the majority opinion

Justice Jackson wrote for a unanimous Court in part and for the Court in part, resolving a dispute over which States could claim abandoned proceeds from certain prepaid financial instruments sold by MoneyGram. The question was whether the instruments were covered by the federal Disposition of Abandoned Money Orders and Traveler's Checks Act rather than the common law escheat rules. The Court held that the instruments were sufficiently similar to money orders to fall within the Act. It reasoned that they function like money orders because they are prepaid instruments used to transfer a specified amount to a named payee, and that applying common-law rules would create the same inequitable result the Act was meant to fix, since MoneyGram did not keep creditor address records. The Court also rejected Delaware's argument that the instruments were excluded as “third party bank checks,” finding that phrase undefined and unsupported as a broad exclusion. The exceptions were overruled, and the matter was remanded.

Opinion written by Justice Jackson

Decided 28 Feb 2023 · Official report

usrep115598.pdfOpen in a new tab