Bittner v. United States

Questions presented

SCOTUS records, cert granted 21 Jun 2022

This case presents a direct and acknowledged conflict regarding an important question of statutory construction under the Bank Secrecy Act, 31 U.S.C. 5311 et seq., which generally requires taxpayers to report their interests in foreign bank accounts. Under the Act, Congress instructed the Treasury Secretary to ''require a resident or citizen of the United States * * * to keep records, file reports, or keep records and file reports, when the * * * person makes a transaction or maintains a relation for any person with a foreign financial agency." 31 U.S.C. 5314(a). The Secretary's corresponding regulations require filing a single annual report (called an "FBAR") for anyone with an aggregate balance over $10,000 in foreign accounts. 31 C.F.R. 1010.350(a), 1010.306(c). The Act authorizes a $10,000 maximum penalty for any non-willful violation of Section 5314. See 31 U.S.C. 5321(a)(5)(A)-(B). In the decision below, the Fifth Circuit held that there is a separate violation (with its own $10,000 penalty) for each foreign account not timely reported on an annual FBAR; it thus authorized a penalty on "a per-account, not a per-form, basis." In so holding, the Fifth Circuit expressly rejected a contrary decision of the Ninth Circuit, which held the failure to file an annual FBAR constitutes a single violation, "no matter the number of accounts." This critical issue arises all the time, and the Act's penalties for identically situated parties will now turn on whether the taxpayer is from California or Texas. The question presented is: Whether a "violation" under the Act is the failure to file an annual FBAR (no matter the number of foreign accounts), or whether there is a separate violation for each individual account that was not properly reported.

Opinion summary

Etalia.ai summary of the majority opinion

The Court held that the Bank Secrecy Act’s $10,000 maximum penalty for a nonwillful failure to file a compliant foreign bank account report applies per report, not per account. Justice Gorsuch wrote the opinion for the Court in part. The Court reasoned that the statute speaks in terms of the duty to file reports and the penalties for violating that duty, not in terms of individual accounts. It also noted that Congress used account-based language elsewhere in the same provision for certain willful violations and for the reasonable cause exception, which suggested it did not intend the nonwillful penalty to work that way. The Court also relied on the statute’s structure, the implementing regulations, and prior government guidance. It reversed the Fifth Circuit and remanded.

Dissent summary

Etalia.ai summary of the dissenting opinions

Justice Barrett, joined by Justices Thomas, Sotomayor, and Kagan, argued that the statute’s reporting duty is account-specific, so each failure to report a qualifying foreign account is a separate violation. The dissent said the text of sections 5314 and 5321, along with the regulations, treats the obligation as requiring disclosure of each account and makes “violation” an account-based concept. It also argued that the Court confused the annual FBAR form with the statutory report and that the Government could properly assess a separate penalty for each unreported account.

Opinion written by Justice Gorsuch

Decided 28 Feb 2023 · Official report

598us1r6_0813.pdfOpen in a new tab

Oral argument transcript

Argued 2 Nov 2022

21-1195_q8l1.pdfOpen in a new tab