Polselli v. Internal Revenue Service

Questions presented

SCOTUS records, cert granted 9 Dec 2022

The Internal Revenue Code generally requires the IRS, when it serves a summons on a third-party recordkeeper for records pertaining to a person "identified in the summons," to give that identified person notice of the summons. I.R.C. § 7609(a)(l). If the IRS issues a summons directing a bank to produce an accountholder's records, for example, it must generally notify that accountholder of the summons. Section 7609 then provides that "any person who is entitled to notice of a summons under subsection (a) shall have the right to begin a proceeding to quash" that summons in district court. Id. § 7609(b)(2); see id. § 7609(h) (l). In other words, only a person entitled to notice of a summons can seek judicial review of that summons. There are a few exceptions to the notice requirement. As relevant here, the IRS need not provide notice of "any summons ... issued in aid of the collection of (i) an assessment made or judgment rendered against the person with respect to whose liability the summons is issued; or (ii) the liability at law or in equity of any transferee or fiduciary of any person referred to in clause (i)." Id. § 7609(c)(2)(D). The question presented is whether the § 7609(c)(2)(D)(i) exception applies only when the delinquent taxpayer owns or has a legal interest in the summonsed records (as the Ninth Circuit holds), or whether the exception applies to a summons for anyone's records whenever the IRS thinks that person's records might somehow help it collect a delinquent taxpayer's liability (as the Sixth Circuit, joining the Seventh Circuit, held below).

Opinion summary

Etalia.ai summary of the majority opinion

The dispute was whether the IRS had to give notice before serving summonses for bank and other records when it was trying to collect assessed taxes from Remo Polselli. The Court held that no notice was required under 26 U.S.C. § 7609(c)(2)(D)(i) even though the summoned records belonged to third parties and the delinquent taxpayer had no legal interest in them. Chief Justice Roberts wrote that the statute turns on whether the summons is issued in aid of collecting an assessment made against the taxpayer, and it does not add a legal-interest requirement. The Court also rejected the argument that this reading would make another statutory exception redundant, explaining that the two clauses cover different circumstances. The judgment of the Sixth Circuit was affirmed.

Opinion written by Justice Roberts

Decided 18 May 2023 · Official report

598us2r20_b07d.pdfOpen in a new tab

Oral argument transcript

Argued 29 Mar 2023

21-1599_f64i.pdfOpen in a new tab