The dispute was whether New Jersey could leave the Waterfront Commission Compact on its own, even though New York objected. The Court, in an opinion by Justice Kavanaugh for a unanimous Court, held that New Jersey may unilaterally withdraw. The Compact does not say anything about withdrawal, so the Court looked to background contract principles and state sovereignty. It said the Compact created an indefinite arrangement for ongoing performance, and under the default contract rule at the time, such an agreement could be terminated by either party unless the compact says otherwise. The Court also said the nature of the States’ delegation of sovereign power supported that reading. New York’s arguments based on older compacts, international treaty practice, past disputes, and broader consequences were rejected.