Axon Enterprise v. Federal Trade Commission

Questions presented

SCOTUS records, cert granted 24 Jan 2022

  1. After petitioner acquired an essentially insolvent competitor, it found itself subjected to the review of the Federal Trade Commission (FTC), rather than the Department of Justice (DOJ). While the DOJ route promises early access to judicial review, the FTC track is an altogether different matter. Petitioner faced a series of unreasonable demands from the FTC, and the prospect of “litigating” before administrative law judges insulated by unconstitutional double- for-cause removal restrictions and subject to review by an unaccountable Commission. Rather than resign itself to the ongoing unconstitutional injuries inflicted by the FTC’s process, petitioner filed suit in district court seeking to enjoin the unconstitutional FTC proceedings. That lawsuit focused on constitutional issues collateral to the underlying antitrust issues, but the district court nonetheless dismissed it for want of jurisdiction based on implications drawn from a statutory grant of jurisdiction to review the FTC’s cease-and-desist orders. A divided Ninth Circuit affirmed, with the majority acknowledging that dismissal “makes little sense,” and the dissent contending that dismissal contradicted this Court’s precedents. The questions presented are:
  2. Whether Congress impliedly stripped federal district courts of jurisdiction over constitutional challenges to the Federal Trade Commission’s structure, procedures, and existence by granting the courts of appeals jurisdiction to “affirm, enforce, modify, or set aside” the Commission’s cease-and-desist orders.
  3. Whether, on the merits, the structure of the Federal Trade Commission, including the dual-layer for-cause removal protections afforded its administrative law judges, is consistent with the Constitution.

Opinion summary

Etalia.ai summary of the majority opinion

The Court held that the statutory review schemes in the Securities Exchange Act and the Federal Trade Commission Act do not prevent federal district courts from hearing constitutional challenges to the structure or existence of the SEC or FTC. The respondents had gone to district court instead of first completing the agencies’ administrative process, arguing that the agencies’ proceedings were unconstitutional because of the protections for administrative law judges, and in Axon’s case also because the FTC combines prosecutorial and adjudicatory functions. Writing for the Court, Justice Kagan applied the Thunder Basin factors and concluded that these claims would not get meaningful judicial review if delayed, were collateral to the ordinary enforcement proceedings, and were outside the agencies’ expertise. The Court therefore held that district court jurisdiction under 28 U. S. C. § 1331 was not displaced.

Opinion written by Justice Kagan

Decided 14 Apr 2023 · Official report

598us1r10_febh.pdfOpen in a new tab

Oral argument transcript

Argued 7 Nov 2022

21-86_5g68.pdfOpen in a new tab