Questions presented
SCOTUS records, cert granted 27 Jun 2022
In Arbaugh v. Y & H Corp., this Court clarified that limitations on judicial relief should not be treated as jurisdictional absent a clear statement by Congress. At least six circuits have held that 11 U .S.C. 363(m) does not limit the appellate courts' jurisdiction to review unstayed bankruptcy court sale orders, but rather limits only the remedies available in such an appeal. By its plain terms, Section 363(m) presupposes a "reversal or modification on appeal" of a sale order, and specifies only that such reversal or modification "does not affect the validity of [the] sale" to a good faith purchaser, leaving the courts free to fashion other remedies without that effect. In the present case, the Second Circuit held, to the contrary, that Section 363(m) deprived the appellate courts of jurisdiction over an appeal from a lease assignment order deemed "integral" to an already completed sale order, notwithstanding that: the sale order was not contingent on the assignment; the sale price was fixed without regard to whether the lease could be assigned; and respondent had expressly waived (in successfully opposing a stay) any argument that Section 363(m) would bar appellate review. A month later, the Fifth Circuit re-confirmed that it also treats Section 363(m) as jurisdiction-stripping. The question presented is: Whether Bankruptcy Code Section 363(m) limits the appellate courts' jurisdiction over any sale order or order deemed "integral" to a sale order, such that it is not subject to waiver, and even when a remedy could be fashioned that does not affect the validity of the sale.
Opinion summary
Etalia.ai summary of the majority opinion
The dispute arose from Sears's Chapter 11 bankruptcy and the assignment of a lease at the Mall of America to Transform Holdco's designee. MOAC objected to the assignment, lost in Bankruptcy Court, and then won in District Court before the Second Circuit held that Bankruptcy Code § 363(m) deprived the court of jurisdiction. The Supreme Court held that § 363(m) is not jurisdictional. Justice Jackson wrote that the statute does not speak in jurisdictional terms, does not govern a court's adjudicatory power, and instead imposes a limit on the effect of an appeal. The Court also rejected Transform's mootness argument, concluding that MOAC still sought effectual appellate relief. The judgment was vacated and the case remanded.
Opinion written by Justice Jackson
Decided 19 Apr 2023 · Official report
Oral argument transcript
Argued 5 Dec 2022