Yegiazaryan v. Smagin

Questions presented

SCOTUS records, cert granted 13 Jan 2023

In RJR Nabisco, this Court, applying the presumption against extraterritoriality, held that a civil RICO plaintiff states a cognizable claim under RICO's private right of action only if it alleges a "domestic"-not foreign-injury. 579 U.S. 325, 354 (2016). The Court left unresolved, however, what legal test determines whether an injury is foreign or domestic. Id. ("[D]isputes may arise as to whether a particular alleged in- jury is 'foreign' or 'domestic.' But we need not concern ourselves with that question in this case."). Since RJR Nabisco, the Courts of Appeals have divided three ways as to the proper legal test for assessing whether a foreign plaintiff suffers a "domestic" injury to intangible property-such as court judgments, arbitration awards, contract rights, patents, and business reputation or goodwill. The question presented is: Does a foreign plaintiff state a cognizable civil RICO claim when it suffers an injury to intangible property, and if so, under what circumstances.

Opinion summary

Etalia.ai summary of the majority opinion

A Russian judgment creditor sued in California under RICO, claiming the defendants used fraud, witness tampering, obstruction, and other racketeering acts to stop him from collecting on a California judgment against a California resident. The District Court dismissed the case because the plaintiff lived in Russia, but the Ninth Circuit reversed. The Court, in an opinion by Justice Sotomayor, held that a plaintiff alleges a domestic injury under 18 U. S. C. § 1964(c) when the circumstances surrounding the injury show it arose in the United States. The Court rejected a bright-line rule tying injury to the plaintiff's residence and instead adopted a context-specific inquiry focused on the nature of the injury, the racketeering activity that caused it, and its aims and effects. Applying that approach, the Court concluded that the alleged injury arose in the United States because the scheme targeted enforcement of a California judgment, much of the conduct occurred in the United States, and the effects were felt in California.

Dissent summary

Etalia.ai summary of the dissenting opinions

Justice Alito dissented, joined by Justice Thomas and joined by Justice Gorsuch as to Part I. He argued that the Court resolved very little and announced no workable rule for deciding where an intangible RICO injury is located. In his view, the decision gives lower courts almost no guidance, risks confusion in extraterritoriality doctrine, and should have been avoided. He would have dismissed the writ of certiorari as improvidently granted.

Opinion written by Justice Sotomayor

Decided 22 Jun 2023 · Official report

599us1r43_jhek.pdfOpen in a new tab

Oral argument transcript

Argued 25 Apr 2023

22-381_2135.pdfOpen in a new tab