Cases of the 1860 term

68 cases, in order of decision.

  1. Henry T. Bulkley, Claimant of the Barque Edwin, Appellant, v. the Naumakeag Steam Cotton Company

    65 U.S. 386 · Decided 31 Dec 1860 · Justice Nelson

    In the case of Henry T. Bulkley, Claimant of the Barque Edwin v. The Naumkeag Steam Cotton Company, Bulkley appealed a decision by the District Court that found him liable for damages to goods shipped on his vessel from…

  2. John Fitch, Appellant, v. Edward Creighton

    65 U.S. 159 · Decided 31 Dec 1860 · Justice McLean

    John Fitch, appellant, brought a case against Edward Creighton in the Supreme Court.

  3. Russell Sturgis, Claimant of the Steam-Tug Hector, Her Tackle, &c., Impleaded with the Ship Wisconsin, Her Tackle, &c., Appellants, v. Herman Boyer, Albert Woodruff, and Jeremiah R. Robinson, Owners of the Lighter Republic, Libellants

    65 U.S. 110 · Decided 31 Dec 1860 · Justice Clifford

    In the case of Russell Sturgis, claimant of the steam-tug Hector, her tackle and etc., impleaded with the ship Wisconsin, her tackle and etc. v. Herman Boyer, Albert Woodruff and Jeremiah R. Robinson owners of the light…

  4. The Rector, Church Wardens, and Vestrymen, of Christ Church, in the City of Philadelphia, in Trust for Christ Church Hospital, Plaintiffs in Error, v. the County of Philadelphia

    65 U.S. 300 · Decided 2 Jan 1861 · Justice Campbell

    The Rector, Church Wardens, and Vestrymen of Christ Church in the City of Philadelphia brought a case against the County of Philadelphia.

  5. Henry Amey, Plaintiff, v. the Mayor, Aldermen, and Citizens of Allegheny City

    65 U.S. 364 · Decided 7 Jan 1861 · Justice Wayne

    Henry Amey, the plaintiff in this case, was a resident of Allegheny City.

  6. Angelina R. Eberly and Peyton Lytle, by His Next Friend, A. B. Eberly, Plaintiffs in Error, v. Lewis Moore and Charles Raylon

    65 U.S. 147 · Decided 7 Jan 1861 · Justice Campbell

    In the case of Angelina R. Eberly and Peyton Lytle, by his next friend A. B. Eberly v Lewis Moore and Charles Raylon, the plaintiffs in error alleged that they were entitled to a tract of land located in Texas which was…

  7. Braddock Jones, Plaintiff in Error, v. James G. Soulard

    65 U.S. 41 · Decided 7 Jan 1861 · Justice Catron

    This case was heard by the United States Supreme Court in 1860.

  8. Joseph C. Palmer, Charles W. Cook. Bethuel Phelps, and Dexter R. Wright, Appellants, v. the United States

    65 U.S. 125 · Decided 7 Jan 1861 · Justice Grier

    This Supreme Court case involved four appellants, Joseph C. Palmer, Charles W. Cook, Bethuel Phelps and Dexter R. Wright who were appealing a decision made by the United States District Court for the Eastern District of…

  9. The United States, Appellants, v. Claude Chana, William Martin, Thomas P. Turner, and Albert Rowe

    65 U.S. 131 · Decided 7 Jan 1861 · Justice Campbell

    The United States brought an appeal against Claude Chana, William Martin, Thomas P. Turner and Albert Rowe for the alleged violation of a law that prohibited citizens from trading with Native Americans without permissio…

  10. Migral Davila, Plaintiff in Error, v. David Mumford and Jesse Mumford

    65 U.S. 214 · Decided 14 Jan 1861 · Justice Nelson

    Migral Davila brought a case against David and Jesse Mumford in the Supreme Court.

  11. Christopher G. Pearce and Others, Incorporated and Acting Under the Name of the Miles Works, Appellants, v. Jesse W. Page and Others, Claimants of the Steamboat Doctor Robertson

    65 U.S. 228 · Decided 15 Jan 1861 · Justice McLean

    In the case of Christopher G. Pearce and Others, Incorporated v. Jesse W. Page and Others, the Supreme Court was tasked with determining who had rightful claim to a steamboat called Doctor Robertson.

  12. James A. Chandler, Plaintiff in Error, v. Otto Von Roeder, Hamilton Ledbetter, and Charles Von Rosenburg

    65 U.S. 224 · Decided 21 Jan 1861 · Justice Campbell

    In the case of James A. Chandler v. Otto Von Roeder, Hamilton Ledbetter, and Charles Von Rosenberg, Chandler brought a suit against the defendants for damages due to an alleged breach of contract.

  13. Robert Gue, Appellant, v. the Tide Water Canal Company

    65 U.S. 257 · Decided 21 Jan 1861 · Justice Taney

    In the case of Robert Gue v. The Tide Water Canal Company, appellant Robert Gue sued the canal company for damages to his property caused by their negligence in constructing a dam across a stream that ran through his la…

  14. The Lessee of Isaiah Frost and Others, Plaintiffs in Error, v. the Frostburg Coal Company

    65 U.S. 278 · Decided 21 Jan 1861 · Justice Nelson

    In this Supreme Court case, the Lessee of Isaiah Frost and others brought a suit against the Frostburg Coal Company.

  15. James Nations and Joseph Nations, Plaintiffs in Error, v. Nancy Ann Johnson and James Johnson

    65 U.S. 195 · Decided 21 Jan 1861 · Justice Clifford

    In the case of James Nations and Joseph Nations v. Nancy Ann Johnson and James Johnson, the plaintiffs in error argued that they had a valid contract with the defendants to purchase land from them.

  16. Thomas Richardson, Plaintiff in Error, v. the City of Boston

    65 U.S. 188 · Decided 21 Jan 1861 · Justice Grier

    In the case of Thomas Richardson v. The City of Boston, the plaintiff argued that he was wrongfully arrested and imprisoned for a debt owed to the city.

  17. George R. Sampson and Lewis W. Tappan, Merchants Doing Business Under the Names and Firm of Sampson & Tappan, Claimants of the Ship Sarah, Her Tackle, Apparel, and Furniture, Appellants, v. Samuel Welsh, John Welsh, and William Welsh, Trad

    65 U.S. 207 · Decided 21 Jan 1861 · Justice Taney

    In the case of George R. Sampson and Lewis W. Tappan, Merchants doing business under the names and firm of Sampson & Tappan, Claimants of the Ship Sarah, her Tackle, Apparel, and Furniture v Samuel Welsh et al., merchan…

  18. John C. Almy, Jun., Plaintiff in Error, v. the People of the State of California

    65 U.S. 169 · Decided 28 Jan 1861 · Justice Taney

    John C. Almy, Jun., brought a case before the United States Supreme Court challenging his conviction in California for selling liquor without a license.

  19. William A. Hall, Plaintiff in Error, v. Joseph L. Papin

    65 U.S. 132 · Decided 28 Jan 1861 · Justice Wayne

    In the case of William A. Hall v. Joseph L. Papin, Hall was suing for damages due to a breach of contract between himself and Papin regarding the sale of certain real estate in Louisiana.

  20. William H. Phillips, Plaintiff in Error, v. George Page

    65 U.S. 164 · Decided 28 Jan 1861 · Justice Nelson

    In the case of William H. Phillips v. George Page, the Supreme Court was asked to decide whether a contract between two parties could be enforced in court if it had been made without consideration and with no intention…

  21. William Thompson and John Pickell, Plaintiffs in Error, v. Lewis Roberts, Gideon R. Burbank, and Addison Roberts

    65 U.S. 233 · Decided 28 Jan 1861 · Justice Grier

    William Thompson and John Pickell brought a case against Lewis Roberts, Gideon R. Burbank, and Addison Roberts to the Supreme Court of the United States.

  22. Susan Vigel, Plaintiff in Error, v. Henry Naylor, Administrator of George Naylor, Deceased

    65 U.S. 208 · Decided 28 Jan 1861 · Justice Catron

    Susan Vigel, plaintiff in error, brought a case against Henry Naylor, administrator of George Naylor who had passed away.

  23. The Washington, Alexandria, and Georgetown Steam-Packet Company, Plaintiffs in Error, v. Frederic E. Sickles and Trueman Cook.

    65 U.S. 333 · Decided 28 Jan 1861 · Justice Campbell

    In The Washington, Alexandria, and Georgetown Steam-Packet Company v. Frederic E. Sickles and Trueman Cook, the Supreme Court was asked to decide whether a contract between two parties could be enforced when one of them…

  24. Henry S. Foote, Plaintiff in Error, v. Cyrus W. Egery and Joseph F. Smith

    65 U.S. 267 · Decided 4 Feb 1861 · Justice Campbell

    Henry S. Foote, plaintiff in error, brought a case against Cyrus W. Egery and Joseph F. Smith for the recovery of damages resulting from an alleged breach of contract by the defendants to purchase certain lands owned by…

  25. Henry M. Kellogg and Others v. Robert Forsyth

    65 U.S. 186 · Decided 4 Feb 1861 · Justice Campbell

    In the case of Henry M. Kellogg and Others v. Robert Forsyth, the Supreme Court was asked to decide whether a state court had jurisdiction over an action brought by citizens from one state against citizens from another…

  26. Thomas M. League, Plaintiff in Error, v. Cyrus W. Egery, Joseph F. Smith, and Sarah A. Smith, Administratrix

    65 U.S. 264 · Decided 4 Feb 1861 · Justice Campbell

    Thomas M. League brought a case against Cyrus W. Egery, Joseph F. Smith and Sarah A. Smith, Administratrix in the United States Supreme Court in 1860.

  27. Charles F. Mayer, Surviving Permanent Trustee of John Gooding, Appellant, v. William Pinkney White, Administrator de Bonis Non of John Gooding and Robert M. Gibbes and Charles Oliver, Surviving Executors of Robert Oliver, Deceased

    65 U.S. 317 · Decided 4 Feb 1861 · Justice Nelson

    Charles F. Mayer, the surviving permanent trustee of John Gooding, appealed to the United States Supreme Court against William Pinkney White, Administrator de bonis non of John Gooding and Robert M. Gibbes and Charles O…

  28. The United States, Appellants, v. Jose Castro and Others

    65 U.S. 346 · Decided 4 Feb 1861 · Justice Taney

    In the United States Supreme Court case of The United States v. Jose Castro and Others, the court was asked to decide whether a Mexican citizen who had been living in California since 1845 could be considered an inhabit…

  29. George B. Bissell, David T. Robinson, and Calvin Day, Plaintiffs in Error, v. the City of Jeffersonville

    65 U.S. 287 · Decided 11 Feb 1861 · Justice Clifford

    This case involved a dispute between the plaintiffs in error, George B. Bissell, David T. Robinson and Calvin Day, and the City of Jeffersonville over an ordinance passed by the city council that imposed a tax on all pe…

  30. John Greer and Others, Plaintlffs in Error, v. S. M. Mezes, Maria de La Solidad Ortega de Arguello, and Jose Ramon Arguello

    65 U.S. 268 · Decided 11 Feb 1861 · Justice Grier

    John Greer and others brought a case against S.M. Mezes, Maria de la Solidad Ortega de Arguello, and Jose Ramon Arguello to the Supreme Court of the United States in 1860.

  31. William S. Mcewen and Henry H. Wiley, Plaintiffs in Error, v. John Den, Lessee of Charles Bulkley and Stuart Brown

    65 U.S. 242 · Decided 13 Feb 1861 · Justice Catron

    In the case of William S. McEwen and Henry H. Wiley v John Den, Lessee of Charles Bulkley and Stuart Brown, the plaintiffs in error argued that they had a valid contract with the defendants for certain lands located in…

  32. Joseph H. Adler, Lewis Schiff, Solomon Adler, and Lobe Rindskoff, Plaintiffs in Error, v. Aaron D. Fenton, Oliver H. Lee, William H. Davis, and Merrit T. Cole

    65 U.S. 407 · Decided 18 Feb 1861 · Justice Campbell

    Joseph H. Adler, Lewis Schiff, Solomon Adler and Lobe Rindskoff were the plaintiffs in error in this Supreme Court case against Aaron D. Fenton, Oliver H. Lee, William H. Davis and Merrit T. Cole as defendants in error.

  33. John D. Clements, Appellant, v. Jonathan R. Warner

    65 U.S. 394 · Decided 18 Feb 1861 · Justice Campbell

    John D. Clements, appellant, brought a case against Jonathan R. Warner in the Supreme Court of the United States.

  34. The Cleveland Insurance Company, Appellante, v. George Reed, Juliet S. Reed, James H. Rogers, and the Milwaukie and Mississippi Railroad Company

    65 U.S. 284 · Decided 18 Feb 1861 · Justice Catron

    The Cleveland Insurance Company (appellant) brought a case against George Reed, Juliet S. Reed, James H. Rogers and the Milwaukie and Mississippi Railroad Company (respondents).

  35. John M. Fackler, Appellant, v. John R. Ford and Others

    65 U.S. 322 · Decided 18 Feb 1861 · Justice Grier

    John M. Fackler appealed to the United States Supreme Court after a lower court ruled against him in his case against John R. Ford and others.

  36. John T. Martin, Andrew Proudfit, and John Keefe, Plaintiffs in Error, v. William H. Thomas and Robert A. Baker, Administrators of Major J. Thomas, Deceased, Use of George T. Rogers

    65 U.S. 315 · Decided 18 Feb 1861 · Justice McLean

    John T. Martin, Andrew Proudfit, and John Keefe (plaintiffs in error) brought a case against William H. Thomas and Robert A. Baker (administrators of Major J. Thomas), with the use of George T. Rogers as defendant in er…

  37. Franklin Moore, George Foot, and George F. Bagley, Plaintiffs in Error. v. the American Transportation Company

    65 U.S. 1 · Decided 18 Feb 1861 · Justice Nelson

    In the case of Franklin Moore, George Foot and George F. Bagley v The American Transportation Company, the plaintiffs in error argued that they had been wrongfully charged for freight on goods shipped from New York to P…

  38. The Powhatan Steamboat Company, Plaintiffs in Error, v. the Appomattox Railroad Company

    65 U.S. 247 · Decided 18 Feb 1861 · Justice Clifford

    The Powhatan Steamboat Company brought a case against the Appomattox Railroad Company to the Supreme Court.

  39. Charles Tate and Others, Plaintiffs in Error, v. John G. Carney and Others

    65 U.S. 357 · Decided 18 Feb 1861 · Justice Campbell

    Charles Tate and others brought a case against John G. Carney and others in the Supreme Court of the United States.

  40. William Wiggins, James M. Jones, and John B. Weller, Complainants, v. John B. Gray and Knowles Taylor

    65 U.S. 303 · Decided 18 Feb 1861 · Justice Taney

    This Supreme Court case involved William Wiggins, James M. Jones, and John B. Weller as complainants against John B. Gray and Knowles Taylor.

  41. Charles Mcmicken Perin, Clyde Perin, and Mary E. Perin, Infants, by Their Father and Next Friend, Franklin Perin, Complainants and Appellants, v. Freeman G. Carey, William Crossman, and William M. F. Hewson, Executors of the Last Will and Test

    65 U.S. 465 · Decided 25 Feb 1861 · Justice Wayne

    This US Supreme Court case is between Charles McMicken Perin, Clyde Perin, and Mary E. Perin (infants) represented by their father Franklin Perin as complainants and appellants against Freeman G. Carey, William Crossman…

  42. The Union Steamship Company of Philadelphia, Claimants and Owners of the Steamship Pennsylvania, Her Tackle, &c., Appellants, v. the New York and Virginia Steamship Company

    65 U.S. 307 · Decided 25 Feb 1861 · Justice Clifford

    The Union Steamship Company of Philadelphia (Claimants and Owners) appealed a case against the New York and Virginia Steamship Company.

  43. George W. Day, Bowen Matlock, Isaac H. Frothingham, and George W. Warner, Plaintiffs in Error, v. William A. Washburn and John A. Keith

    65 U.S. 352 · Decided 5 Mar 1861 · Justice Nelson

    This case was brought before the United States Supreme Court by George W. Day, Bowen Matlock, Isaac H. Frothingham and George W. Warner (Plaintiffs in Error) against William A. Washburn and John A. Keith (Defendants).

  44. Lessee of Robert W. Smith and Carey W. Butt, Plaintiff in Error, v. William Mccann

    65 U.S. 398 · Decided 5 Mar 1861 · Justice Taney

    In the case of Lessee of Robert W. Smith and Carey W. Butt v William McCann, the Supreme Court was asked to decide whether a lessee had rights to use timber on land they leased from another party for mining purposes.

  45. Phelps v. Edgerton

    131 U.S. lxxi · Decided 5 Mar 1861 · Justice Taney

    Phelps v. Edgerton was a case heard by the United States Supreme Court in 1860.

  46. Charles Ballance, Appellant, v. Robert Forsyth, Luciene Dumain, and Antoine R. Bouis

    65 U.S. 183 · Decided 14 Mar 1861 · Justice Campbell

    In the case of Charles Ballance v. Robert Forsyth, Luciene Dumain, and Antoine R. Bouis, the Supreme Court was asked to decide whether a Louisiana state court had jurisdiction over a dispute between two citizens of diff…

  47. William H. Belcher and Charles Belcher, Plaintiffs in Error, v. William A. Linn

    65 U.S. 508 · Decided 14 Mar 1861 · Justice Clifford

    In the case of William H. Belcher and Charles Belcher v. William A. Linn, the Supreme Court was asked to decide whether a deed from an executor of a will could be considered valid if it had not been approved by the cour…

  48. Pierre A. Berthold, Alfred C. Bernondy, and Marklat Thompson, Plaintiffs in Error, v. Edward Goldsmith

    65 U.S. 536 · Decided 14 Mar 1861 · Justice Clifford

    In the case of Pierre A. Berthold, Alfred C. Bernondy and Marklat Thompson v Edward Goldsmith, the plaintiffs in error were challenging a decision by the Supreme Court of Louisiana which had denied them their right to r…

  49. Ex Parte. in the Matter of the Commonwealth of Kentucky, One of the United States of America, by Beriah Magoffin, Governor, and the Executive Authority Thereof, Petitioner, v. William Dennison, Governor and Executive Authority of the State O

    65 U.S. 66 · Decided 14 Mar 1861 · Justice Taney

    Ex Parte in the Matter of the Commonwealth of Kentucky is a Supreme Court case that involves Beriah Magoffin, Governor and Executive Authority thereof, as petitioner against William Dennison, Governor and Executive Auth…

  50. Jacob E. Curtis, Plaintiff, v. the County of Butler

    65 U.S. 435 · Decided 14 Mar 1861 · Justice Wayne

    Jacob E. Curtis brought a case against the County of Butler to the Supreme Court in 1860.

  51. Davidson v. Lanier

    131 U.S. lxxii · Decided 14 Mar 1861 · Justice Taney

    Davidson v. Lanier was a case heard by the United States Supreme Court in 1860.

  52. Wstson Freeman, Marshal of the United States, Plaintiff in Error, v. Jabez C. Howe, John H. Wilkins, and William Minot, Jun

    65 U.S. 450 · Decided 14 Mar 1861 · Justice Nelson

    This Supreme Court case involves Watson Freeman, the Marshal of the United States, as plaintiff in error.

  53. Myra Clark Gaines, Appellant, v. Duncan N. Hennen

    65 U.S. 553 · Decided 14 Mar 1861 · Justice Wayne

    Myra Clark Gaines, appellant, brought a case against Duncan N. Hennen in the Supreme Court of the United States.

  54. Richard Gregg and Charles Ballance, Plaintiffs in Error, v. Robert Forsyth

    65 U.S. 179 · Decided 14 Mar 1861 · Justice Campbell

    In the case of Richard Gregg and Charles Ballance v. Robert Forsyth, the plaintiffs in error argued that a contract between them and Forsyth was invalid due to an alleged lack of consideration.

  55. Thacker B. Howard, Plaintiff in Error, v. Francis Bugbee

    65 U.S. 461 · Decided 14 Mar 1861 · Justice Nelson

    In Thacker B. Howard v. Francis Bugbee, the Supreme Court of the United States heard a case involving an appeal from a decision by the Circuit Court for Washington County in Maryland.

  56. James D. Porter and Others, Plaintiffs in Error, v. Bushrod W. Foley

    65 U.S. 415 · Decided 14 Mar 1861 · Justice Grier

    The Supreme Court case of James D. Porter and Others v. Bushrod W. Foley was a dispute over the ownership of land in Illinois that had been granted to veterans by Congress for their service during the War of 1812, but w…

  57. Joseph A. Sheirburn, Plaintiff in Error, v. Jacob de Cordova and Others

    65 U.S. 423 · Decided 14 Mar 1861 · Justice Campbell

    Joseph A. Sheirburn brought a case against Jacob de Cordova and others in the Supreme Court of the United States, arguing that he had been wrongfully deprived of his property rights.

  58. James Knight, James H. West, and Robert Sargeant, Plaintiffs in Error, v. Augustus Schell

    65 U.S. 526 · Decided 14 Mar 1861 · Justice Clifford

    In the case of James Knight, James H. West and Robert Sargeant v. Augustus Schell, the plaintiffs in error brought a suit against Schell for damages caused by his negligence while operating a steamboat on the Mississipp…

  59. Samuel Massey and Others, Plaintiffs in Error, v. Joseph L. Papin

    65 U.S. 362 · Decided 14 Mar 1861 · Justice Catron

    In the case of Samuel Massey and Others v. Joseph L. Papin, the Supreme Court was asked to decide whether a contract between two parties could be enforced when it had been made without consideration or any other form of…

  60. Arnold Medberry, John Lawhead, Robert H. Nugen, and Abner J. Dickenson, Plaintiffs in Error, v. the State of Ohio

    65 U.S. 413 · Decided 14 Mar 1861 · Justice Grier

    In the case of Arnold Medberry, John Lawhead, Robert H. Nugent and Abner J. Dickenson v. The State of Ohio, the plaintiffs in error were challenging a decision by an Ohio court that had sentenced them to two years impri…

  61. William C. Reddall, Plaintiff in Error, v. William H. Bryan, Alfred L. Rives, William H. Piles, John Cameron, James Paine, Charles Hutchinson, and John Moore

    65 U.S. 420 · Decided 14 Mar 1861 · Justice Taney

    In the case of William C. Reddall v. William H. Bryan, Alfred L. Rives, William H. Piles, John Cameron, James Paine, Charles Hutchinson and John Moore (Reddall v Bryan), the plaintiff in error claimed that he had been w…

  62. James H. Suydam, Plaintiff in Error, v. William H. Williamson

    65 U.S. 427 · Decided 14 Mar 1861 · Justice Campbell

    James H. Suydam was the plaintiff in error in a case against William H. Williamson, which went before the United States Supreme Court.

  63. The Board of Commissioners of Knox County, Plaintiffs in Error, v. William H. Aspinwall, Joseph W. Alsop, Henry Chancey, Charles Gould, and Samuel L. M. Barlow

    65 U.S. 376 · Decided 14 Mar 1861 · Justice Grier

    The Board of Commissioners of Knox County, Tennessee brought a case against William H. Aspinwall, Joseph W. Alsop, Henry Chancey, Charles Gould and Samuel L. M. Barlow for the collection of taxes on certain lands in the…

  64. Thomas Meehan and Charles Ballance, Plaintiffs in Error, v. Robert Forsyth

    65 U.S. 175 · Decided 14 Mar 1861 · Justice Campbell

    Thomas Meehan and Charles Ballance were plaintiffs in error in a Supreme Court case against Robert Forsyth.

  65. Alfred Tracy, Surviving Partner of Edward Tracy, Plaintiff in Error, v. William Holcombe

    65 U.S. 426 · Decided 14 Mar 1861 · Justice Taney

    Alfred Tracy, the surviving partner of Edward Tracy, brought a case against William Holcombe to the Supreme Court.

  66. John J. Wheeler, Plaintiff in Error, v. Andrew J. Nesbitt, Jerome Carding, Frederick M. Binkley, James D. Trimble, Wilson J. Mathis, and Robert Mcneely

    65 U.S. 544 · Decided 14 Mar 1861 · Justice Clifford

    John J. Wheeler brought a case before the Supreme Court against Andrew J. Nesbitt, Jerome Carding, Frederick M. Binkley, James D. Trimble, Wilson J. Mathis and Robert McNeely for damages incurred in an altercation betwe…

  67. William H. Belcher and Charles Belcher, Plaintiffs in Error, v. William A. Linn

    65 U.S. 533 · Decided 14 Mar 1861 · Justice Clifford

    In the case of William H. Belcher and Charles Belcher v. William A. Linn, the Supreme Court was asked to decide whether a contract between two parties is valid if it does not contain all of its essential terms in writin…

  68. Rice vs. Railroad Company

    66 U.S. 358 · Decided 3 Mar 1862 · Justice Clifford

    In Rice v. Railroad Company, the Supreme Court of the United States held that a railroad company was liable for damages caused by its negligence in failing to provide sufficient protection against fire on its premises.