Federal Taxation cases, page 12

1,536 cases, terms 1796 to 2024, newest first. 1101 to 1200 on this page.

Federal Taxation
  1. United States v. Verdier

    164 U.S. 213 · Decided 16 Nov 1896 · Justice Brown

    In the United States v. Verdier case of 1896, the Supreme Court ruled on a matter concerning customs duties and importation laws.

  2. Saltonstall v. Birtwell

    164 U.S. 54 · Decided 26 Oct 1896 · Justice Shiras

    The Saltonstall v. Birtwell case in 1896 revolved around a dispute over the interpretation of customs duties on imported goods.

  3. United States v. Allen

    163 U.S. 499 · Decided 25 May 1896 · Justice White

    In the United States v. Allen case of 1895, the Supreme Court ruled on a dispute involving land ownership in Kansas.

  4. United States v. Fitch

    163 U.S. 631 · Decided 25 May 1896 · Justice Brown

    In the United States v. Fitch case of 1895, the Supreme Court dealt with a dispute over land ownership in California.

  5. United States v. Realty Company.

    163 U.S. 427 · Decided 25 May 1896 · Justice Peckham

    In the case of United States v. Realty Company (1895), the U.S Supreme Court dealt with a dispute over land ownership in St. Louis, Missouri between private entities and the federal government.

  6. United States v. Healey

    160 U.S. 136 · Decided 2 Dec 1895 · Justice Harlan

    In the United States v. Healey case of 1895, the Supreme Court ruled on a matter concerning customs duties.

  7. Dejonge v. Magone

    159 U.S. 562 · Decided 18 Nov 1895 · Justice White

    In the DeJonge v. Magone case of 1895, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled in favor of DeJonge, a stockholder who sued Magone, a collector of customs at the port of New York for refunding duties paid under protest on imported…

  8. Magone v. Wiederer

    159 U.S. 555 · Decided 18 Nov 1895 · Justice White

    In the case of Magone v. Wiederer, 1895, the United States Supreme Court ruled on a matter concerning customs duties.

  9. Patton v. United States

    159 U.S. 500 · Decided 11 Nov 1895 · Justice Brown

    In the case of Patton v. United States, 1895, the U.S Supreme Court ruled on a matter concerning land ownership and rights in Oklahoma.

  10. Sonn v. Magone

    159 U.S. 417 · Decided 11 Nov 1895 · Justice Fuller

    In the case of Sonn v. Magone in 1895, the United States Supreme Court ruled on a dispute involving import duties.

  11. United States v. Burr

    159 U.S. 78 · Decided 3 Jun 1895 · Justice Fuller

    In the United States v. Burr case of 1894, Aaron Burr was indicted for treason against the U.S. government due to his alleged plan to separate territories from the U.S and establish an independent nation under his contr…

  12. Kennedy v. Magone

    158 U.S. 212 · Decided 20 May 1895 · Justice White

    In Kennedy v. Magone, the Supreme Court of the United States ruled on a dispute involving customs duties.

  13. Pollock v. Farmers' Loan and Trust Company. (Rehearing)

    158 U.S. 601 · Decided 20 May 1895 · Justice Fuller

    The Pollock v. Farmers' Loan and Trust Company case in 1894 was a landmark decision by the U.S Supreme Court that declared federal income taxes unconstitutional.

  14. Hyde v. Continental Trust Company

    157 U.S. 654 · Decided 8 Apr 1895 · Justice Fuller

    The Hyde v. Continental Trust Company case in 1894 revolved around a dispute over the payment of bonds issued by the New Orleans, Mobile and Texas Railroad company.

  15. Pollock v. Farmers' Loan and Trust Company

    157 U.S. 429 · Decided 8 Apr 1895 · Justice Fuller

    The Pollock v. Farmers' Loan and Trust Company case in 1894 was a landmark decision by the U.S. Supreme Court that declared federal income taxes unconstitutional.

  16. Barney v. Rickard

    157 U.S. 352 · Decided 1 Apr 1895 · Justice Fuller

    In the case of Barney v. Rickard in 1894, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled on a dispute regarding land ownership and mining rights in Colorado.

  17. Seeberger v. Wright and Lawther Oil and Lead Manufacturing Company

    157 U.S. 183 · Decided 18 Mar 1895 · Justice Brown

    The U.S. Supreme Court case Seeburger v. Wright and Lawther Oil and Lead Manufacturing Company in 1894 revolved around a dispute over property rights, specifically the right to mine lead on certain lands in Iowa.

  18. Beuttell v. Magone

    157 U.S. 154 · Decided 11 Mar 1895 · Justice White

    Beuttell v. Magone, 1894, is a U.S Supreme Court case that revolved around the issue of import duties on sugar.

  19. Cooper v. Dobson

    157 U.S. 148 · Decided 11 Mar 1895 · Justice Shiras

    In the case of Cooper v. Dobson in 1894, the United States Supreme Court dealt with a dispute over land ownership and mineral rights.

  20. Saltonstall v. Wiebusch

    156 U.S. 601 · Decided 4 Mar 1895 · Justice Brown

    The Saltonstall v. Wiebusch case in 1894 revolved around a dispute over the ownership of certain lands in California.

  21. Muser v. Magone

    155 U.S. 240 · Decided 3 Dec 1894 · Justice Fuller

    In the case of Muser v. Magone in 1894, the United States Supreme Court ruled on a dispute involving import duties.

  22. Origet v. Hedden

    155 U.S. 228 · Decided 3 Dec 1894 · Justice Fuller

    In the 1894 U.S. Supreme Court case of Orget v. Hedden, the court was tasked with determining whether a certain type of French silk fabric known as "silk grenadines" should be classified under tariff laws as a manufactu…

  23. Erhardt v. Schroeder

    155 U.S. 124 · Decided 12 Nov 1894 · Justice Shiras

    In the case of Erhardt v. Schroeder (1894), the U.S Supreme Court dealt with a dispute over property rights and inheritance laws.

  24. Seeberger v. Schweyer

    153 U.S. 609 · Decided 14 May 1894 · Justice Shiras

    In the case of Seeberger v. Schweyer in 1893, the U.S Supreme Court was tasked with determining whether a contract for sale and delivery of goods between parties residing in different states constituted interstate comme…

  25. Stewart v. Barnes

    153 U.S. 456 · Decided 14 May 1894 · Justice Shiras

    In the case of Stewart v. Barnes, 1893, the U.S Supreme Court was tasked with deciding on a dispute over land ownership in Utah.

  26. Erhardt v. Steinhard

    153 U.S. 177 · Decided 23 Apr 1894 · Justice Fuller

    The U.S. Supreme Court case Erhardt v. Steinhart in 1893 revolved around a dispute over the estate of a deceased man, Mr. Erhardt, who had left his property to his wife and children in Germany while also having signific…

  27. Lutz v. Magone

    153 U.S. 105 · Decided 23 Apr 1894 · Justice Brown

    In the case of Lutz v. Magone, 1893, the United States Supreme Court was tasked with determining whether a collector of customs had the right to seize imported goods that were undervalued by their importer in order to a…

  28. Seeberger v. Castro

    153 U.S. 32 · Decided 16 Apr 1894 · Justice White

    In the 1893 U.S. Supreme Court case of Seeberger v. Castro, the court examined a dispute over land ownership in California that had its origins in Mexican law prior to California's admission as a state.

  29. Spalding v. Castro

    153 U.S. 38 · Decided 16 Apr 1894 · Justice White

    In Spalding v. Castro (1893), the United States Supreme Court ruled on a dispute involving land rights in California, which had been granted by Mexico prior to its cession to the U.S. The plaintiff, Spalding, claimed ow…

  30. Bogle v. Magone

    152 U.S. 623 · Decided 9 Apr 1894 · Justice Gray

    In Bogle v. Magone, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled on a dispute involving customs duties.

  31. Presson v. Russell

    152 U.S. 577 · Decided 9 Apr 1894 · Justice Fuller

    In the case of Presson v. Russell in 1893, the U.S Supreme Court dealt with a dispute over land ownership.

  32. Saltonstall v. Russell

    152 U.S. 628 · Decided 9 Apr 1894 · Justice Gray

    In the Saltonstall v. Russell case of 1893, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled on a dispute involving land ownership and inheritance rights.

  33. Seeberger v. Schlesinger

    152 U.S. 581 · Decided 9 Apr 1894 · Justice Brown

    In the Seeburger v. Schlesinger case of 1893, the U.S Supreme Court ruled on a dispute involving property rights and inheritance laws.

  34. Herrman v. Robertson

    152 U.S. 521 · Decided 2 Apr 1894 · Justice Fuller

    In the 1893 case of Herrman v. Robertson, the U.S. Supreme Court was asked to determine whether a New York law that prohibited non-residents from dredging oysters in its waters violated the Privileges and Immunities Cla…

  35. Berbecker v. Robertson

    152 U.S. 373 · Decided 12 Mar 1894 · Justice Fuller

    In the case of Berbecker v. Robertson in 1893, the U.S Supreme Court was tasked with deciding on a dispute involving maritime law and personal injury liability.

  36. Maddock v. Magone

    152 U.S. 368 · Decided 12 Mar 1894 · Justice Fuller

    In the 1893 case Maddock v. Magone, the United States Supreme Court ruled on a dispute involving customs duties.

  37. Hedden v. Robertson

    151 U.S. 520 · Decided 5 Feb 1894 · Justice Jackson

    In the 1893 case of Hedden v. Robertson, the United States Supreme Court was tasked with determining whether a certain type of woolen cloth could be classified as worsted fabric under customs law.

  38. Cadwalader v. Zeh

    151 U.S. 171 · Decided 8 Jan 1894 · Justice Gray

    In the 1893 U.S. Supreme Court case Cadwalader v. Zeh, the court ruled on a dispute involving customs duties and importation laws.

  39. Seeberger v. Hardy.

    150 U.S. 420 · Decided 4 Dec 1893 · Justice Brown

    The U.S. Supreme Court case Seeburger v. Hardy, 1893, revolved around a dispute over land ownership in the state of California.

  40. Magone v. Heller

    150 U.S. 70 · Decided 30 Oct 1893 · Justice Gray

    In the case of Magone v. Heller in 1893, the United States Supreme Court ruled on a dispute concerning import duties.

  41. Cadwalader v. Wanamaker

    149 U.S. 532 · Decided 15 May 1893 · Justice Shiras

    In the 1892 case of Cadwalader v. Wanamaker, John Wanamaker, a Philadelphia merchant and Postmaster General under President Benjamin Harrison, was sued by George Cadwalader for alleged non-payment of duties on imported…

  42. Hartranft v. Meyer

    149 U.S. 544 · Decided 15 May 1893 · Justice Shiras

    In the Hartranft v. Meyer case of 1892, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled in favor of John F. Hartranft, Superintendent of the Eastern State Penitentiary in Philadelphia, against an inmate named Meyer who was serving a life…

  43. Walker v. Seeberger

    149 U.S. 541 · Decided 15 May 1893 · Justice Shiras

    In the Walker v. Seeberger case of 1892, the U.S Supreme Court ruled on a dispute over land ownership in Chicago.

  44. Cadwalader v. Jessup and Moore Paper Company

    149 U.S. 350 · Decided 10 May 1893 · Justice Blatchford

    In the 1892 case of Cadwalader v. Jessup and Moore Paper Company, the U.S. Supreme Court dealt with a dispute over tax law.

  45. Hedden v. Richard

    149 U.S. 346 · Decided 10 May 1893 · Justice Shiras

    In the 1892 case Hedden v. Richard, the U.S. Supreme Court was tasked with determining whether a certain type of cotton fabric could be classified as "colored" under tariff laws, which would subject it to higher duties…

  46. Hollender v. Magone

    149 U.S. 586 · Decided 10 May 1893 · Justice Brewer

    In the 1892 case Hollender v. Magone, the United States Supreme Court ruled on a dispute involving customs duties.

  47. Nix v. Hedden

    149 U.S. 304 · Decided 10 May 1893 · Justice Gray

    In the 1892 U.S. Supreme Court case Nix v. Hedden, the court was tasked with determining whether a tomato should be classified as a fruit or vegetable under customs regulations.

  48. Hager v. Swayne

    149 U.S. 242 · Decided 1 May 1893 · Justice Fuller

    In the Hager v. Swayne case of 1892, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled on a dispute involving land ownership and inheritance laws in California.

  49. United States v. Isaacs

    148 U.S. 654 · Decided 10 Apr 1893 · Justice Gray

    In the United States v. Isaacs case of 1892, the Supreme Court ruled on a matter concerning customs duties.

  50. Manhattan Company v. Blake

    148 U.S. 412 · Decided 3 Apr 1893 · Justice Blatchford

    The Manhattan Company v. Blake case in 1892 revolved around a dispute over the rights to use water from the Collect Pond in New York City for commercial purposes.

  51. Arnold v. United States

    147 U.S. 494 · Decided 6 Feb 1893 · Justice Brewer

    In the 1892 case Arnold v. United States, the Supreme Court ruled on a matter involving maritime law and salvage rights.

  52. Mcmullen v. United States

    146 U.S. 360 · Decided 5 Dec 1892 · Justice Harlan

    In McMullen v. United States (1892), the U.S Supreme Court ruled on a case involving an individual who was convicted of perjury during his naturalization proceedings.

  53. Junge v. Hedden

    146 U.S. 233 · Decided 28 Nov 1892 · Justice Fuller

    In the 1892 case of Junge v. Hedden, the U.S. Supreme Court was tasked with determining whether a tariff on vegetables applied to tomatoes, which are scientifically classified as fruits but commonly considered vegetable…

  54. United States v. Perry

    146 U.S. 71 · Decided 7 Nov 1892 · Justice Brown

    In the United States v. Perry case of 1892, the Supreme Court ruled on a dispute involving land ownership in California.

  55. United States v. Schoverling

    146 U.S. 76 · Decided 7 Nov 1892 · Justice Blatchford

    In the United States v. Schoverling case of 1892, the Supreme Court ruled on a matter concerning import duties.

  56. Earnshaw v. Cadwalade

    145 U.S. 247 · Decided 16 May 1892 · Justice Blatchford

    In the case of Earnshaw v. Cadwalade, 1891, the Supreme Court dealt with a dispute over property rights and inheritance.

  57. Rossman v. Hedden

    145 U.S. 561 · Decided 16 May 1892 · Justice Fuller

    In the 1891 case of Rossman v. Hedden, the United States Supreme Court was tasked with determining whether a tax imposed on imported goods applied to certain types of fabric.

  58. Meyerheim v. Robertson

    144 U.S. 601 · Decided 18 Apr 1892 · Justice Blatchford

    In the Meyerheim v. Robertson case of 1891, the US Supreme Court dealt with a dispute over patent rights.

  59. Robertson v. Salomon

    144 U.S. 603 · Decided 18 Apr 1892 · Justice Blatchford

    In the 1891 case of Robertson v. Salomon, the U.S. Supreme Court was tasked with determining whether a New York law that allowed for the seizure and sale of imported goods due to unpaid rent violated federal laws govern…

  60. Isaacs v. Jonas

    148 U.S. 648 · Decided 10 Apr 1892 · Justice Gray

    In the case of Isaacs v. Jonas in 1892, the U.S Supreme Court ruled on a dispute involving bankruptcy and property rights.

  61. Heinze v. Arthur'S Executors

    144 U.S. 28 · Decided 14 Mar 1892 · Justice Blatchford

    In the case of Heinze v. Arthur's Executors, 1891, the U.S Supreme Court was tasked with determining whether a contract for the sale of goods could be enforced if it had not been fully executed at the time one party die…

  62. Liebenroth v. Robertson

    144 U.S. 35 · Decided 14 Mar 1892 · Justice Blatchford

    The Liebenroth v. Robertson case in 1891 revolved around a dispute over the ownership of certain goods that were seized by U.S. customs officials due to non-payment of duties.

  63. United States v. Ballin

    144 U.S. 1 · Decided 29 Feb 1892 · Justice Brewer

    The United States v. Ballin case in 1891 revolved around the interpretation of what constitutes a quorum in the U.S. House of Representatives for conducting business, as per Article One, Section Five of the Constitution…

  64. United States v. Witten

    143 U.S. 76 · Decided 1 Feb 1892 · Justice Gray

    In the United States v. Witten case of 1891, the Supreme Court ruled on a dispute over land rights in Oklahoma.

  65. Hedden v. Iselin

    142 U.S. 676 · Decided 26 Jan 1892 · Justice Blatchford

    In the case of Hedden v. Iselin, 1891, the U.S Supreme Court was tasked with determining whether a certain type of woolen cloth known as "ladies' cloth" could be classified under the tariff act for duty purposes as a wo…

  66. Magone v. Rosenstein

    142 U.S. 604 · Decided 11 Jan 1892 · Justice Fuller

    In the case of Magone v. Rosenstein, 1891, the United States Supreme Court ruled on a dispute involving import duties.

  67. Phelps v. Siegfried

    142 U.S. 602 · Decided 11 Jan 1892 · Justice Fuller

    In the case of Phelps v. Siegfried, 1891, the US Supreme Court dealt with a dispute over land ownership in Kansas.

  68. Thompson v. United States

    142 U.S. 471 · Decided 11 Jan 1892 · Justice Brown

    In the case of Thompson v. United States in 1891, the Supreme Court ruled on a matter involving maritime law and insurance claims.

  69. American Net and Twine Company v. Worthington

    141 U.S. 468 · Decided 9 Nov 1891 · Justice Brown

    In the case of American Net and Twine Company v. Worthington, 1891, the U.S Supreme Court ruled in favor of Worthington.

  70. Chicago Distilling Company v. Stone

    140 U.S. 647 · Decided 25 May 1891 · Justice Bradley

    In the case of Chicago Distilling Company v. Stone in 1890, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled on a dispute involving tax laws related to distilled spirits.

  71. Dwight v. Merritt

    140 U.S. 213 · Decided 11 May 1891 · Justice Lamar

    In the case of Dwight v. Merritt, 1890, the U.S Supreme Court was tasked with resolving a dispute over land ownership in New York City.

  72. Redfield v. Bartels

    139 U.S. 694 · Decided 20 Apr 1891 · Justice Fuller

    In the Redfield v. Bartels case of 1890, the U.S Supreme Court was tasked with resolving a dispute over land ownership in California.

  73. Magone v. Luckemeyer

    139 U.S. 612 · Decided 13 Apr 1891 · Justice Blatchford

    In the case of Magone v. Luckemeyer, 1890, the U.S. Supreme Court was asked to determine whether a tax collector could be held personally liable for taxes collected on imported goods that were later found to have been i…

  74. Mason v. Robertson

    139 U.S. 624 · Decided 13 Apr 1891 · Justice Gray

    In the case of Mason v. Robertson, 1890, the United States Supreme Court ruled on a dispute involving land ownership and mining rights in California.

  75. Seeberger v. Farwell

    139 U.S. 608 · Decided 13 Apr 1891 · Justice Blatchford

    In the 1890 U.S. Supreme Court case of Seeberger v. Farwell, the court examined a dispute over property rights and inheritance law.

  76. Worthington v. Robbins

    139 U.S. 337 · Decided 30 Mar 1891 · Justice Blatchford

    In the Worthington v. Robbins case of 1890, the U.S Supreme Court ruled on a dispute involving land ownership and property rights.

  77. Schell'S Executors v. Fauche

    138 U.S. 562 · Decided 2 Mar 1891 · Justice Brown

    In Schell's Executors v. Fauche, the U.S. Supreme Court was asked to rule on a dispute over an estate inheritance involving international law and jurisdictional issues.

  78. United States v. Connor

    138 U.S. 61 · Decided 19 Jan 1891 · Justice Brewer

    In the United States v. Connor case of 1890, the Supreme Court ruled on a dispute involving land ownership in California.

  79. Cadwalader v. Partridge

    137 U.S. 553 · Decided 22 Dec 1890 · Justice Lamar

    In the case of Cadwalader v. Partridge (1890), the US Supreme Court dealt with a dispute over property rights and inheritance laws.

  80. Merritt v. Cameron

    137 U.S. 542 · Decided 22 Dec 1890 · Justice Lamar

    In the Merritt v. Cameron case of 1890, the U.S Supreme Court ruled on a dispute involving land ownership in Washington D.C. The plaintiff, Merritt, claimed that he had purchased a piece of property from one Mr. Barry a…

  81. Robertson v. Oelschlaeger.

    137 U.S. 436 · Decided 22 Dec 1890 · Justice Bradley

    In the Robertson v. Oelschlaeger case of 1890, the U.S Supreme Court was tasked with resolving a dispute over land ownership in California.

  82. Auffmordt v. Hedden

    137 U.S. 310 · Decided 8 Dec 1890 · Justice Blatchford

    In the Auffmordt v. Hedden case of 1890, the U.S Supreme Court ruled on a dispute involving import duties.

  83. Falk v. Robertson

    137 U.S. 225 · Decided 24 Nov 1890 · Justice Blatchford

    In the case of Falk v. Robertson, the U.S Supreme Court in 1890 ruled on a dispute involving copyright law and its application to dramatic works.

  84. Seeberger v. Cahn

    137 U.S. 95 · Decided 17 Nov 1890 · Justice Gray

    The U.S. Supreme Court case Seerberger v. Cahn in 1890 revolved around a dispute over the ownership of certain lands situated in St. Louis, Missouri.

  85. Harding v. Woodcock

    137 U.S. 43 · Decided 3 Nov 1890 · Justice Field

    In the case of Harding v. Woodcock (1890), the U.S Supreme Court dealt with a dispute over land ownership in Maine.

  86. Hartranft v. Meyer

    135 U.S. 237 · Decided 28 Apr 1890 · Justice Brewer

    HARTANFT v. MEYER was a Supreme Court case that was decided in 1884.

  87. United States v. Sanborn.

    135 U.S. 271 · Decided 28 Apr 1890 · Justice Harlan

    United States v. Sanborn was a Supreme Court case decided in 1867.

  88. Richmond v. Blake

    132 U.S. 592 · Decided 6 Jan 1890 · Justice Harlan

    The Supreme Court case of Richmond v. Blake was a case that was heard in 1820.

  89. Robertson v. Edelhoff

    132 U.S. 614 · Decided 6 Jan 1890 · Justice Blatchford

    Robertson v. Edelhoff was a Supreme Court case that was decided in 1892.

  90. Forbes Lithograph Manufacturing Company v. Worthington

    132 U.S. 655 · Decided 23 Dec 1889 · Justice Fuller

    Forbes Lithograph Manufacturing Company v. Worthington was a Supreme Court case that was decided in 1891.

  91. Robertson v. Bradbury

    132 U.S. 491 · Decided 16 Dec 1889 · Justice Bradley

    Robertson v. Bradbury is a Supreme Court case from 1820 that dealt with the issue of whether a state court had the authority to issue a writ of habeas corpus.

  92. Robertson v. Gerdan

    132 U.S. 454 · Decided 16 Dec 1889 · Justice Blatchford

    Robertson v. Gerdan was a Supreme Court case that was decided in 1891.

  93. Robertson v. Rosenthal

    132 U.S. 460 · Decided 16 Dec 1889 · Justice Fuller

    Robertson v. Rosenthal was a case heard by the Supreme Court of the United States in 1933.

  94. Pickhardt v. Merritt

    132 U.S. 252 · Decided 2 Dec 1889 · Justice Blatchford

    Pickhardt v. Merritt is a Supreme Court case from 1891 that dealt with the issue of whether a tenant was entitled to compensation for improvements made to a leased property.

  95. Sherman v. Robertson

    136 U.S. 570 · Decided 2 Dec 1889

    Sherman v. Robertson was a Supreme Court case from 1935 that dealt with the issue of whether a state could require a person to pay a fee in order to obtain a license to practice a profession.

  96. United States v. Barlow

    132 U.S. 271 · Decided 2 Dec 1889 · Justice Field

    United States v. Barlow is a Supreme Court case from 1978 that dealt with the issue of whether the federal government had the authority to regulate the safety of employees in the workplace.

  97. Merritt v. Tiffany

    132 U.S. 167 · Decided 18 Nov 1889 · Justice Field

    Merritt v. Tiffany was a Supreme Court case from 1837.

  98. Robertson v. Glendenning

    132 U.S. 158 · Decided 18 Nov 1889 · Justice Fuller

    Robertson v. Glendenning was a Supreme Court case that was decided in 1891.

  99. Robertson v. Frank Brothers Company

    132 U.S. 17 · Decided 28 Oct 1889 · Justice Bradley

    Robertson v. Frank Brothers Company was a case heard by the United States Supreme Court in 1935.

  100. Robertson v. Salomon

    130 U.S. 412 · Decided 15 Apr 1889 · Justice Bradley

    Robertson v. Salomon was a landmark Supreme Court case that established the concept of corporate separateness.