Questions presented
SCOTUS records, cert granted 13 Jan 2023
Whether, to establish that a statement is a "true threat" unprotected by the First Amendment, the government must show that the speaker subjectively knew or intended the threatening nature of the statement, or whether it is enough to show that an objective "reasonable person" would regard the statement as a threat of violence.
Opinion summary
Etalia.ai summary of the majority opinion
The Court held that a criminal prosecution for a true threat requires proof that the defendant had some subjective understanding of the threatening nature of his statements, and that recklessness is enough. Writing for the Court, Justice Kagan said true threats are unprotected by the First Amendment, but the Constitution still requires a mental-state safeguard to reduce the risk that protected speech will be chilled. The Court reasoned that other unprotected categories of speech, such as defamation, also use subjective fault standards, and that recklessness strikes the right balance between protecting expression and allowing states to punish dangerous threats. Because Colorado applied only an objective reasonable-person test and did not have to show Counterman knew or consciously disregarded the risk that his messages would be seen as threatening, the conviction violated the First Amendment. The judgment was vacated and remanded.
Dissent summary
Etalia.ai summary of the dissenting opinions
Justice Thomas wrote a dissenting opinion, joined by Justice Barrett. Thomas said the majority wrongly relied on New York Times v. Sullivan and extended a policy-driven First Amendment analysis to true threats. Justice Barrett, joined by Thomas, argued that true threats are unprotected speech and that nearly every other category of unprotected speech may be regulated under an objective standard, so the Court improperly granted true threats special constitutional protection by requiring recklessness.
Opinion written by Justice Kagan
Decided 27 Jun 2023 · Official report
Oral argument transcript
Argued 19 Apr 2023