Questions presented
SCOTUS records, cert granted 3 Oct 2022
It is a bedrock principle of federalism that a statute does not abrogate sovereign immunity unless Congress's intent to abrogate is "unmistakably clear'' in the statutory text. Dellmuth v. Muth, 491 U.S. 223, 228 (1989). This Court and each of the other Circuits have held that a statute granting the federal courts jurisdiction over a category of claims without expressly addressing sovereign immunity does not abrogate. See, e.g., Blatchford v. Native Vill. of Noatak, 501 U.S. 775, 786 & n.4 (1991). The First Circuit nevertheless held, over a vigorous dissent, that 48 U.S.C. § 2126 (a) of the Puerto Rico Oversight, Management, and Economic Stability Act (PROMESA)-which grants federal jurisdiction over claims against the Financial Oversight and Management Board for Puerto Rico and claims otherwise arising out of PROMESA, but says nothing about abrogation-eliminates the Board's immunity in its totality. While acknowledging that the statutory language "may not be as precise" as other instances of abrogation, the court held that certain provisions "impl[y]" that result. It did so even though jurisdiction was necessary for those claims not subject to immunity. The Question Presented is: Does 48 U.S.C.§ 2126(a)'s general grant of jurisdiction to the federal courts over claims against the Board and claims otherwise arising under PROMESA abrogate the Board's sovereign immunity with respect to all federal and territorial claims?
Opinion summary
Etalia.ai summary of the majority opinion
The dispute was whether PROMESA categorically abrogates any sovereign immunity the Financial Oversight and Management Board for Puerto Rico may have, in a suit by a media organization seeking public records. The Court held that it does not. Justice Kagan wrote that Congress must make abrogation unmistakably clear, and PROMESA does not explicitly strip the Board of immunity, create a cause of action against it, or otherwise clearly authorize suit against it. The Court also said PROMESA’s provisions on federal jurisdiction, declaratory and injunctive relief, monetary liability, and challenges to budgetary decisions are all compatible with the Board generally retaining sovereign immunity. The Court reversed and remanded.
Dissent summary
Etalia.ai summary of the dissenting opinions
Justice Thomas dissented. He argued that the Court should have decided first whether the Board actually has the sovereign immunity it claims, because CPI had preserved that argument and it was logically antecedent to the abrogation issue. He also questioned whether the Board, as a territorial entity rather than a State, could claim the same inherent sovereign immunity that States enjoy. In his view, the Board had not shown that it possessed the immunity it asserted, so he would have affirmed for CPI.
Opinion written by Justice Kagan
Decided 11 May 2023 · Official report
Oral argument transcript
Argued 11 Jan 2023