Santos-Zacaria v. Garland

Questions presented

SCOTUS records, cert granted 3 Oct 2022

  1. After the Board of Immigration Appeals (BIA) denied her application for withholding of removal, petitioner Leon Santos-Zacaria filed a petition for review. Although the government agreed that the court had jurisdiction, the Fifth Circuit sua sponte dismissed in part for lack of jurisdiction pursuant to 8 U.S.C. § 1252(d)(1), which requires a noncitizen to exhaust "all administrative remedies available to the alien as of right." This holding implicates two circuit splits, each of which independently warrants review.
  2. Eight circuits hold that Section 1252(d)(1)'s exhaustion requirement is jurisdictional. Two circuits disagree, holding that exhaustion may be waived. Multiple courts and judges have called for further review of this issue. The first question presented is: Whether Section 1252(d)(1)'s exhaustion requirement is jurisdictional, or merely a mandatory claims processing rule that may be waived or forfeited.
  3. Further, petitioner's merits argument is that the BIA engaged in impermissible fact finding. In these circumstances, the Fifth Circuit, along with three other circuits, requires a noncitizen to file a motion to reopen or reconsider with the agency in order to satisfy Section 1252(d)(1)'s requirement that a noncitizen exhaust "remedies available * * * as of right." Two other circuits, recognizing that "[t]he decision to grant or deny a motion to reopen or reconsider is within the discretion of the Board" (8 C.F.R. § 1003.2) disagree. The second question presented is: Whether, to satisfy Section 1252(d)(1)'s exhaustion requirement, a noncitizen who challenges a new error introduced by the BIA must first ask the agency to exercise its discretion to reopen or reconsider.

Opinion summary

Etalia.ai summary of the majority opinion

The case asked whether 8 U.S.C. § 1252(d)(1) requires a noncitizen to exhaust administrative remedies before seeking judicial review of a removal order, and whether that exhaustion rule is jurisdictional. Writing for the Court, Justice Jackson held that the provision is not jurisdictional because Congress did not clearly say so. The Court also held that the statute requires only remedies available “as of right,” which does not include discretionary Board of Immigration Appeals reconsideration. So a noncitizen does not have to ask the Board to reconsider an unfavorable decision before filing a petition for review. The Court therefore vacated the Fifth Circuit’s judgment and remanded.

Opinion written by Justice Jackson

Decided 11 May 2023 · Official report

598us2r19_dc8f.pdfOpen in a new tab

Oral argument transcript

Argued 17 Jan 2023

21-1436_7p84.pdfOpen in a new tab