Tyler v. Hennepin County, Minnesota

Questions presented

SCOTUS records, cert granted 13 Jan 2023

  1. Hennepin County confiscated 93-year-old Geraldine Tyler's former home as payment for approximately $15,000 in property taxes, penalties, interest, and costs. The County sold the home for $40,000, and, consistent with a Minnesota forfeiture statute, kept all proceeds, including the $25,000 that exceeded Tyler's debt as a windfall for the public. In all states, municipalities may take real property and sell it to collect payment for property tax debts. Most states allow the government to keep only as much as it is owed; any surplus proceeds after collecting the debt belong to the former owner. But in Minnesota and a dozen other states, local governments take absolute title, extinguishing the owner's equity in exchange only for cancelling a smaller tax debt, code enforcement fine, or debt to government agencies. The questions presented are:
  2. Whether taking and selling a home to satisfy a debt to the government, and keeping the surplus value as a windfall, violates the Takings Clause?
  3. Whether the forfeiture of property worth far more than needed to satisfy a debt plus, interest, penalties, and costs, is a fine within the meaning of the Eighth Amendment?

Opinion summary

Etalia.ai summary of the majority opinion

Geraldine Tyler’s condominium was sold by Hennepin County for $40,000 to satisfy about $15,000 in unpaid property taxes, and the County kept the $25,000 surplus. The Court held that Tyler plausibly alleged a violation of the Takings Clause because the County could collect the tax debt but could not keep more than it was owed. The Court said the surplus was protected property under state law, history, and precedent, and that Minnesota could not avoid just compensation by treating the excess as unclaimed or as if Tyler had abandoned the property. Chief Justice Roberts delivered the opinion of the Court.

Opinion written by Justice Roberts

Decided 25 May 2023 · Official report

598us2r27_aplc.pdfOpen in a new tab

Oral argument transcript

Argued 26 Apr 2023

22-166_h4d8.pdfOpen in a new tab