Questions presented
SCOTUS records, cert granted 28 Feb 2022
- In 1978, Congress enacted the Indian Child Welfare Act ("ICWA") to remedy the "alarmingly high percentage of Indian families [being] broken up by the removal, often unwarranted, of their children by nontribal public and private agencies." 25 U.S.C. §1901(4). Over the ensuing four decades, state courts have repeatedly sustained ICWA as constitutional, and child-welfare professionals now regard ICWA's procedural and substantive requirements as the gold standard for child welfare. Below, however, the district court struck down much of ICWA. And while the en banc Fifth Circuit rejected most of the district court's reasoning, a sharply divided court invalidated several ICWA provisions. The en banc court also affirmed, by an equally divided court, the district court's judgment invalidating several additional provisions. The questions presented are:
- Did the en banc Fifth Circuit err by invalidating six sets of ICWA provisions-25 U.S.C. §§1912(a), (d), (e)-(f), 1915(a)-(b), (e), and 1951(a)-as impermissibly commandeering States (including via its equally divided affirmance)?
- Did the en banc Fifth Circuit err by reaching the merits of the plaintiffs' claims that ICWA's placement preferences violate equal protection?
- Did the en banc Fifth Circuit err by affirming (via an equally divided court) the district court's judgment invalidating two of ICWA's placement preferences, 25 U.S.C. §1915(a)(3), (b)(iii), as failing to satisfy the rational-basis standard of Morton v. Mancari, 417 U.S. 535 (1974)?
Opinion summary
Etalia.ai summary of the majority opinion
The case involved the Indian Child Welfare Act, which directs state courts in custody, foster care, and adoption proceedings involving Indian children to follow federal placement preferences, notice rules, heightened proof requirements, and related recordkeeping duties. Justice Barrett wrote for the Court. The Court upheld the Act against claims that Congress lacked authority to enact it and that it unlawfully commandeered the States. The Court said Congress has broad power in Indian affairs under longstanding precedent, and that ICWA fits within that authority. It also held that the challenged notice, placement, evidentiary, and recordkeeping provisions do not violate the Tenth Amendment because they apply to private as well as state actors, or because state courts may be required to apply valid federal law and perform ancillary adjudicative tasks. The Court did not reach the equal protection and nondelegation claims because no party before the Court had standing to raise them.
Dissent summary
Etalia.ai summary of the dissenting opinions
Justice Thomas dissented, arguing that Congress lacked constitutional authority to regulate state child custody proceedings just because an Indian child is involved. He said the Indian Commerce Clause does not cover child custody, the Treaty Clause does not apply, and foreign-affairs or structural powers cannot reach ordinary domestic family-law disputes. He also criticized the Court’s “plenary power” and trust-relationship precedents as lacking a constitutional basis and said they should not be extended to this case. The text also notes that Justice Alito filed a dissenting opinion.
Opinion written by Justice Barrett
Decided 15 Jun 2023 · Official report
Oral argument transcript
Argued 9 Nov 2022