Private Action cases, page 13
3,334 cases, terms 1798 to 2023, newest first. 1201 to 1300 on this page.
Sage v. Memphis and Little Rock Railroad Company
125 U.S. 361 · Decided 19 Mar 1888 · Justice HarlanIn Sage v. Memphis and Little Rock Railroad Company, the Supreme Court of the United States was asked to decide whether a railroad company was liable for damages caused by a train accident.
Southern Development Company v. Silva
125 U.S. 247 · Decided 19 Mar 1888 · Justice LamarSouthern Development Company v. Silva was a United States Supreme Court case that addressed the issue of whether a contract between two parties was valid.
Tompkins v. Little Rock and Fort Smith Railway
125 U.S. 109 · Decided 19 Mar 1888 · Justice WaiteTompkins v. Little Rock and Fort Smith Railway was a United States Supreme Court case that dealt with the issue of whether a railroad company was liable for damages caused by its negligence.
Wall v. Bissell
125 U.S. 382 · Decided 19 Mar 1888 · Justice GrayWall v. Bissell was a United States Supreme Court case that dealt with the issue of whether a state court had the authority to issue a writ of mandamus to a federal court.
Crawford v. Halsey
124 U.S. 648 · Decided 20 Feb 1888 · Justice WaiteIn Crawford v. Halsey, the United States Supreme Court was asked to decide whether a contract between two parties was valid.
Dow v. Memphis and Little Rock Railroad Company
124 U.S. 652 · Decided 20 Feb 1888 · Justice WaiteIn the case of Dow v. Memphis and Little Rock Railroad Company, the Supreme Court of the United States was asked to decide whether a railroad company was liable for damages caused by a fire that spread from its property…
Pacific National Bank v. Mixter
124 U.S. 721 · Decided 20 Feb 1888 · Justice WaitePacific National Bank v. Mixter was a United States Supreme Court case that addressed the issue of whether a bank could be held liable for the negligence of its employees.
Shoecraft v. Bloxham
124 U.S. 730 · Decided 20 Feb 1888 · Justice FieldShoecraft v. Bloxham was a United States Supreme Court case that dealt with the issue of whether a state court had the authority to issue an injunction against a state officer.
Aetna Life Insurance Company v. Middleport
124 U.S. 534 · Decided 6 Feb 1888 · Justice MillerAetna Life Insurance Company v. Middleport is a United States Supreme Court case that was decided in 1887.
District of Columbia v. Gallaher
124 U.S. 505 · Decided 6 Feb 1888 · Justice MatthewsDistrict of Columbia v. Gallaher was a United States Supreme Court case that addressed the issue of whether a state could impose a tax on a non-resident's income from real estate located within the state.
Hopkins v. Orr
124 U.S. 510 · Decided 6 Feb 1888 · Justice GrayHopkins v. Orr was a United States Supreme Court case that dealt with the issue of whether a state court had the authority to issue a writ of habeas corpus to a prisoner who was being held in a federal prison.
Trask v. Jacksonville, Pensacola and Mobile Railroad Company
124 U.S. 515 · Decided 6 Feb 1888 · Justice WaiteIn Trask v. Jacksonville, Pensacola and Mobile Railroad Company, the Supreme Court of the United States was asked to decide whether a railroad company was liable for damages caused by a train accident.
Brazee v. Schofield
124 U.S. 495 · Decided 30 Jan 1888 · Justice FieldBrazee v. Schofield was a United States Supreme Court case that dealt with the issue of whether a state court had the authority to issue a writ of habeas corpus to a prisoner who was being held in a federal prison.
Union Insurance Company v. Smith
124 U.S. 405 · Decided 30 Jan 1888 · Justice BlatchfordIn Union Insurance Company v. Smith, the Supreme Court of the United States was asked to decide whether a contract of insurance was valid and enforceable.
Chapin v. Streeter
124 U.S. 360 · Decided 23 Jan 1888 · Justice MillerChapin v. Streeter was a United States Supreme Court case that dealt with the issue of whether a state court had the authority to issue a writ of mandamus to a federal court.
Florence Mining Company v. Brown
124 U.S. 385 · Decided 23 Jan 1888 · Justice FieldIn Florence Mining Company v. Brown, the United States Supreme Court was asked to decide whether a mining company had the right to use a certain portion of a public highway for the purpose of transporting ore from its m…
Iron Silver Mining Company v. Reynolds
124 U.S. 374 · Decided 23 Jan 1888 · Justice FieldIron Silver Mining Company v. Reynolds is a United States Supreme Court case that was decided in 1887.
Shields v. Schiff
124 U.S. 351 · Decided 23 Jan 1888 · Justice BradleyShields v. Schiff was a United States Supreme Court case that dealt with the issue of whether a contract between two parties was valid.
Widdicombe v. Childers
124 U.S. 400 · Decided 23 Jan 1888 · Justice WaiteWiddicombe v. Childers was a United States Supreme Court case that addressed the issue of whether a state court had the authority to issue a writ of habeas corpus to a prisoner held in a federal prison.
Union Railroad Company v. Dull
124 U.S. 173 · Decided 16 Jan 1888 · Justice HarlanIn Union Railroad Company v. Dull, the Supreme Court of the United States was asked to decide whether a railroad company was liable for damages caused by a train accident.
Dundee Mortgage and Trust Investment Company v. Hughes
124 U.S. 157 · Decided 9 Jan 1888 · Justice WaiteIn the case of Dundee Mortgage and Trust Investment Company v. Hughes, the Supreme Court of the United States was asked to determine whether a mortgage deed was valid.
Hinchman v. Lincoln
124 U.S. 38 · Decided 9 Jan 1888 · Justice MatthewsHinchman v. Lincoln was a United States Supreme Court case that dealt with the issue of whether a state court had the authority to issue a writ of habeas corpus to a prisoner held in a federal prison.
Humiston v. Wood
124 U.S. 12 · Decided 9 Jan 1888 · Justice MatthewsIn Humiston v. Wood, the United States Supreme Court was asked to decide whether a contract between two parties was valid and enforceable.
Inland and Seaboard Coasting Company v. Hall
124 U.S. 121 · Decided 9 Jan 1888 · Justice WaiteInland and Seaboard Coasting Company v. Hall was a case heard by the United States Supreme Court in 1887.
Langdon v. Sherwood
124 U.S. 74 · Decided 9 Jan 1888 · Justice MillerLangdon v. Sherwood was a United States Supreme Court case that dealt with the issue of whether a contract between two parties was valid.
Lawson v. Floyd
124 U.S. 108 · Decided 9 Jan 1888 · Justice MillerIn Lawson v. Floyd, the Supreme Court of the United States was asked to decide whether a state court had the authority to issue a writ of habeas corpus to a prisoner who had been convicted in a federal court.
Roberts v. Benjamin
124 U.S. 64 · Decided 9 Jan 1888 · Justice BlatchfordRoberts v. Benjamin was a United States Supreme Court case that dealt with the issue of whether a contract between two parties was valid.
Radford v. Folsom
123 U.S. 725 · Decided 19 Dec 1887 · Justice WaiteIn Radford v. Folsom, the United States Supreme Court addressed the issue of whether a state court could enjoin a federal court from hearing a case.
Robison v. Female Orphan Asylum of Portland
123 U.S. 702 · Decided 19 Dec 1887 · Justice MatthewsIn Robison v. Female Orphan Asylum of Portland, the Supreme Court of the United States was asked to decide whether a charitable trust created by a will was valid.
Talkington v. Dumbleton
123 U.S. 745 · Decided 19 Dec 1887 · Justice WaiteTalkington v. Dumbleton is a United States Supreme Court case that was decided in 1887.
Texas & Pacific Railway Company v. Marlor
123 U.S. 687 · Decided 19 Dec 1887 · Justice BlatchfordIn Texas & Pacific Railway Company v. Marlor, the Supreme Court of the United States was asked to decide whether a railroad company was liable for damages caused by a train accident.
Bond v. Davenport
123 U.S. 619 · Decided 12 Dec 1887 · Justice WaiteBond v. Davenport is a United States Supreme Court case that was decided in 1887.
Wilson v. Riddle
123 U.S. 608 · Decided 12 Dec 1887 · Justice BlatchfordWilson v. Riddle is a United States Supreme Court case that was decided in 1887.
Lacombe v. Forstall'S Sons
123 U.S. 562 · Decided 5 Dec 1887 · Justice MillerLacombe v. Forstall's Sons was a United States Supreme Court case that addressed the issue of whether a contract between two parties was valid.
Spraul v. Louisiana
123 U.S. 516 · Decided 5 Dec 1887 · Justice WaiteIn Spraul v. Louisiana, the United States Supreme Court considered the constitutionality of a Louisiana statute that prohibited the sale of intoxicating liquors within four miles of any schoolhouse.
Plumb v. Goodnow'S Administrato
123 U.S. 560 · Decided 5 Dec 1887 · Justice WaitePlumb v. Goodnow's Administratrix was a United States Supreme Court case in which the Court held that a state court could not exercise jurisdiction over a case involving a federal question.
Smith v. Craft
123 U.S. 436 · Decided 5 Dec 1887 · Justice GraySmith v. Craft was a United States Supreme Court case that addressed the issue of whether a state court could enforce a contract that was made in violation of a state statute.
Teal v. Bilby
123 U.S. 572 · Decided 5 Dec 1887 · Justice MillerTeal v. Bilby was a United States Supreme Court case that addressed the issue of whether a state court had the authority to issue a writ of habeas corpus to a prisoner who was being held in a federal prison.
Colorado Coal and Iron Company v. United States
123 U.S. 307 · Decided 21 Nov 1887 · Justice MatthewsIn Colorado Coal and Iron Company v. United States, the Supreme Court considered the constitutionality of a federal statute that allowed the government to take possession of a coal mine in Colorado.
Hoard v. Chesapeake and Ohio Railway
123 U.S. 222 · Decided 7 Nov 1887 · Justice MillerHoard v. Chesapeake and Ohio Railway was a United States Supreme Court case that dealt with the issue of whether a railroad company was liable for damages caused by a train accident.
Richter v. Jerome
123 U.S. 233 · Decided 7 Nov 1887 · Justice WaiteIn the case of Richter v. Jerome, the United States Supreme Court was asked to decide whether a contract between two parties was valid and enforceable.
Bull v. Bank of Kasson
123 U.S. 105 · Decided 31 Oct 1887 · Justice FieldIn Bull v. Bank of Kasson, the Supreme Court of the United States was asked to decide whether a bank could be held liable for the wrongful acts of its officers.
Davis v. Key
123 U.S. 79 · Decided 31 Oct 1887 · Justice BlatchfordDavis v. Key is a United States Supreme Court case that was decided in 1887.
Tufts v. Tufts
123 U.S. 76 · Decided 31 Oct 1887 · Justice WaiteIn Tufts v. Tufts, the Supreme Court of the United States was asked to decide whether a contract between two parties was valid and enforceable.
Argentine Mining Co. v. Terrible Mining Co
122 U.S. 478 · Decided 27 May 1887 · Justice FieldIn the case of Argentine Mining Co. v. Terrible Mining Co., the Supreme Court of the United States was asked to decide whether a mining company had the right to sue another mining company for damages caused by the latte…
Mcleod v. Fourth National Bank of St. Louis
122 U.S. 528 · Decided 27 May 1887 · Justice MillerIn McLeod v. Fourth National Bank of St. Louis, the Supreme Court of the United States was asked to decide whether a state court had the authority to issue an injunction against a national bank.
Merchants' Insurance Company v. Allen
122 U.S. 376 · Decided 27 May 1887 · Justice WaiteIn Merchants' Insurance Company v. Allen, the Supreme Court of the United States was asked to decide whether a contract of insurance was valid and enforceable.
Morrison v. Durr
122 U.S. 518 · Decided 27 May 1887 · Justice WaiteMorrison v. Durr was a United States Supreme Court case that addressed the issue of whether a state court could enforce a contract that was made in violation of a federal statute.
Porter v. Pittsburg Bessemer Steel Co. (Limited)
122 U.S. 267 · Decided 27 May 1887 · Justice BlatchfordPorter v. Pittsburgh Bessemer Steel Co. (Limited) was a United States Supreme Court case that addressed the issue of whether a contract between two parties was valid.
Shippen v. Bowen
122 U.S. 575 · Decided 27 May 1887 · Justice HarlanShippen v. Bowen was a United States Supreme Court case that dealt with the issue of whether a state court had the authority to issue a writ of habeas corpus to a prisoner held in federal custody.
Simonton v. Sibley
122 U.S. 220 · Decided 27 May 1887 · Justice GraySimonston v. Sibley is a United States Supreme Court case that was decided in 1887.
Struthers v. Drexel
122 U.S. 487 · Decided 27 May 1887 · Justice MatthewsStruthers v. Drexel is a United States Supreme Court case that was decided in 1887.
Travellers' Insurance Company v. Edwards
122 U.S. 457 · Decided 27 May 1887 · Justice MillerIn Travellers' Insurance Company v. Edwards, the Supreme Court of the United States was asked to decide whether a life insurance policy issued by the Travellers' Insurance Company was valid.
Walter v. Bickham
122 U.S. 320 · Decided 27 May 1887 · Justice HarlanWalter v. Bickham was a United States Supreme Court case that addressed the issue of whether a state court could enforce a contract that was made in violation of a federal statute.
Barnes v. Chicago, Milwaukee and St. Paul Railway
122 U.S. 1 · Decided 23 May 1887 · Justice WaiteBarnes v. Chicago, Milwaukee and St. Paul Railway was a United States Supreme Court case that addressed the issue of whether a railroad company was liable for damages caused by a fire that was started by sparks from one…
Davis v. Patrick
122 U.S. 138 · Decided 23 May 1887 · Justice BlatchfordDavis v. Patrick was a United States Supreme Court case that dealt with the issue of whether a state court had the authority to issue a writ of habeas corpus to a prisoner who was being held in a federal prison.
Topliff v. Topliff
122 U.S. 121 · Decided 23 May 1887 · Justice MatthewsIn the case of Topliff v. Topliff, the Supreme Court of the United States was asked to decide whether a husband and wife could enter into a contract to settle their property rights upon divorce.
Frost v. Spitley
121 U.S. 552 · Decided 2 May 1887 · Justice GrayFrost v. Spitley was a United States Supreme Court case that addressed the issue of whether a contract between two parties was valid.
Mcgowan v. American Pressed Tan Bark Company
121 U.S. 575 · Decided 2 May 1887 · Justice BlatchfordIn the case of McGowan v. American Pressed Tan Bark Company, the Supreme Court of the United States was asked to determine whether a state law that prohibited the sale of tan bark in certain forms was unconstitutional.
Albany and Rensselaer Company v. Lundberg
121 U.S. 451 · Decided 25 Apr 1887 · Justice GrayAlbany and Rensselaer Company v. Lundberg was a United States Supreme Court case that addressed the issue of whether a state court could enjoin a railroad company from operating its trains on a particular track.
Milwaukee and Northern Railway Company v. Brooks Locomotive Works
121 U.S. 430 · Decided 25 Apr 1887 · Justice MatthewsIn the case of Milwaukee and Northern Railway Company v. Brooks Locomotive Works, the Supreme Court was asked to decide whether a contract between the two parties was valid.
Wilson'S Executor v. Deen
121 U.S. 525 · Decided 25 Apr 1887 · Justice FieldWilson's Executor v. Deen was a case heard by the United States Supreme Court in 1887.
Hinckley v. Pittsburgh Bessemer Steel Company
121 U.S. 264 · Decided 18 Apr 1887 · Justice BlatchfordHinckley v. Pittsburgh Bessemer Steel Company was a case heard by the United States Supreme Court in 1887.
Huiskamp v. Moline Wagon Co
121 U.S. 310 · Decided 18 Apr 1887 · Justice BlatchfordIn Huiskamp v. Moline Wagon Co, the United States Supreme Court was asked to decide whether a patentee could recover damages for infringement of a patent that had been declared invalid by a court of competent jurisdicti…
Lanier v. Nash
121 U.S. 404 · Decided 18 Apr 1887 · Justice WaiteIn the case of Lanier v. Nash, the Supreme Court of the United States was asked to decide whether a state court had the authority to issue an injunction against a federal officer.
Minneapolis Association v. Canfield
121 U.S. 295 · Decided 18 Apr 1887 · Justice MatthewsIn Minneapolis Association v. Canfield, the United States Supreme Court was asked to decide whether a contract between a Minneapolis association and a real estate developer was valid.
Cleveland Rolling Mill v. Rhodes
121 U.S. 255 · Decided 11 Apr 1887 · Justice GrayCleveland Rolling Mill v. Rhodes was a case heard by the United States Supreme Court in 1887.
Mcconihay v. Wright
121 U.S. 201 · Decided 11 Apr 1887 · Justice MatthewsMcConihay v. Wright was a United States Supreme Court case that dealt with the issue of whether a state court had the authority to issue a writ of mandamus to a county court.
Grant v. Phoenix Life Insurance Company
121 U.S. 105 · Decided 4 Apr 1887 · Justice BlatchfordIn Grant v. Phoenix Life Insurance Company, the Supreme Court of the United States was asked to decide whether a life insurance policy was validly issued.
First National Bank of Cleveland v. Shedd
121 U.S. 74 · Decided 28 Mar 1887 · Justice WaiteIn the case of First National Bank of Cleveland v. Shedd, the Supreme Court of the United States was asked to decide whether a bank could be held liable for a check that was issued without sufficient funds in the accoun…
Richmond v. Iron
121 U.S. 27 · Decided 28 Mar 1887 · Justice MatthewsIn the case of Richmond v. Iron, the Supreme Court of the United States was asked to decide whether a state could impose a tax on a foreign corporation that was doing business within its borders.
United States v. Mcdougall'S Administrator
121 U.S. 89 · Decided 28 Mar 1887 · Justice HarlanUnited States v. McDougall's Administrator was a United States Supreme Court case that dealt with the issue of whether the United States could recover money from a deceased person's estate.
Goodwin v. Fo
120 U.S. 775 · Decided 21 Mar 1887 · Justice WaiteGoodwin v. Fo was a United States Supreme Court case that dealt with the issue of whether a state court had the authority to issue a writ of habeas corpus to a prisoner who was being held in a federal prison.
New Orleans National Banking Association v. Le Breton
120 U.S. 765 · Decided 21 Mar 1887 · Justice BradleyThis case was a dispute between the New Orleans National Banking Association and the defendant, Le Breton.
Porter v. Pittsburg Bessemer Steel Company
120 U.S. 649 · Decided 21 Mar 1887 · Justice BlatchfordPorter v. Pittsburgh Bessemer Steel Company was a United States Supreme Court case that addressed the issue of whether a contract between two parties was valid.
Dushane v. Benedict
120 U.S. 630 · Decided 14 Mar 1887 · Justice GrayDushane v. Benedict was a United States Supreme Court case that addressed the issue of whether a state court had the authority to issue a writ of habeas corpus to a prisoner who was being held in a federal prison.
Fletcher v. Fuller
120 U.S. 534 · Decided 7 Mar 1887 · Justice FieldFletcher v. Fuller was a United States Supreme Court case that addressed the issue of whether a state court had the authority to issue a writ of habeas corpus to a prisoner who was being held in a federal prison.
Gilmer v. Stone
120 U.S. 586 · Decided 7 Mar 1887 · Justice HarlanIn Gilmer v. Stone, the Supreme Court of the United States was asked to decide whether a contract between two parties was valid and enforceable.
Laclede Bank v. Schuler
120 U.S. 511 · Decided 7 Mar 1887 · Justice MillerLaclede Bank v. Schuler was a case heard by the United States Supreme Court in which the Court was asked to determine whether a bank could be held liable for the wrongful acts of its employees.
People'S Savings Bank v. Bates
120 U.S. 556 · Decided 7 Mar 1887 · Justice HarlanIn the case of People's Savings Bank v. Bates, the Supreme Court of the United States was asked to determine whether a bank could be held liable for a check that was issued without sufficient funds in the account.
Speidel v. Henrici
120 U.S. 377 · Decided 7 Mar 1887 · Justice GrayIn Speidel v. Henrici, the Supreme Court of the United States was asked to decide whether a contract between two parties was valid and enforceable.
Farley v. Kittson
120 U.S. 303 · Decided 7 Feb 1887 · Justice GrayIn Farley v. Kittson, the Supreme Court of the United States was asked to decide whether a contract between two parties was valid and enforceable.
Harmon v. Adams
120 U.S. 363 · Decided 7 Feb 1887 · Justice MatthewsHarmon v. Adams was a United States Supreme Court case that addressed the issue of whether a state court had the authority to issue a writ of habeas corpus to a prisoner held in federal custody.
Pensacola Ice Company v. Perry
120 U.S. 318 · Decided 7 Feb 1887 · Justice WaiteIn Pensacola Ice Company v. Perry, the Supreme Court of the United States was asked to decide whether a state court had the authority to issue an injunction against a federal officer.
Sherman v. Jerome
120 U.S. 319 · Decided 7 Feb 1887 · Justice BlatchfordSherman v. Jerome was a United States Supreme Court case that dealt with the issue of whether a contract between two parties was valid.
Boffinger v. Tuyes
120 U.S. 198 · Decided 31 Jan 1887 · Justice MatthewsBoffinger v. Tuyes was a United States Supreme Court case that addressed the issue of whether a state court had the authority to issue a writ of habeas corpus to a prisoner who was being held in a federal prison.
Indianapolis Rolling Mill v. St. Louis, Fort Scott & Wichita Railroad
120 U.S. 256 · Decided 31 Jan 1887 · Justice MillerThis case was a dispute between the Indianapolis Rolling Mill and the St. Louis, Fort Scott & Wichita Railroad.
Meyers v. Block
120 U.S. 206 · Decided 31 Jan 1887 · Justice BradleyMeyers v. Block was a United States Supreme Court case that addressed the issue of whether a state court could issue a writ of habeas corpus to a prisoner who was being held in federal custody.
Phoenix Life Insurance Company v. Raddin
120 U.S. 183 · Decided 31 Jan 1887 · Justice GrayIn Phoenix Life Insurance Company v. Raddin, the Supreme Court of the United States was asked to decide whether a life insurance policy was validly issued.
Little Rock and Fort Smith Railway v. Huntington
120 U.S. 160 · Decided 24 Jan 1887 · Justice FieldIn Little Rock and Fort Smith Railway v. Huntington, the Supreme Court of the United States was asked to decide whether a railway company was liable for damages caused by a collision between two of its trains.
Memphis & Little Rock Railroad v. Dow
120 U.S. 287 · Decided 24 Jan 1887 · Justice HarlanIn Memphis & Little Rock Railroad v. Dow, the United States Supreme Court was asked to decide whether a railroad company was liable for damages caused by a train accident.
Roberts v. Phoenix Life Insurance Company
120 U.S. 86 · Decided 24 Jan 1887 · Justice BlatchfordIn Roberts v. Phoenix Life Insurance Company, the Supreme Court of the United States was asked to decide whether a life insurance policy was valid when the insured had died before the policy was delivered.
United States v. Otis
120 U.S. 115 · Decided 24 Jan 1887 · Justice BlatchfordIn United States v. Otis, the United States Supreme Court considered the question of whether a federal court had jurisdiction to try a criminal case in which the defendant was charged with violating a federal statute.
United States v. Parker
120 U.S. 89 · Decided 24 Jan 1887 · Justice MatthewsUnited States v. Parker is a United States Supreme Court case that dealt with the issue of whether the federal government had the authority to regulate the sale of alcohol in Indian country.
Hubbard v. Invstment Company
119 U.S. 696 · Decided 17 Jan 1887 · Justice MatthewsIn Hubbard v. Investment Company, the United States Supreme Court was asked to decide whether a contract between two parties was valid and enforceable.
Allen v. St. Louis Bank
120 U.S. 20 · Decided 10 Jan 1887 · Justice GrayIn Allen v. St. Louis Bank, the Supreme Court of the United States was asked to decide whether a bank could be held liable for a check that was issued without the knowledge or consent of the payee.
Borer v. Chapman
119 U.S. 587 · Decided 10 Jan 1887 · Justice MatthewsBorer v. Chapman was a United States Supreme Court case that addressed the issue of whether a state court could enforce a contract that was made in violation of a state statute.
Goetz v. Bank of Kansas City
119 U.S. 551 · Decided 10 Jan 1887 · Justice FieldGoetz v. Bank of Kansas City was a United States Supreme Court case that dealt with the issue of whether a bank could be held liable for the negligence of its employees.
Iron Mountain and Helena Railroad v. Johnson
119 U.S. 608 · Decided 10 Jan 1887 · Justice MillerIn Iron Mountain and Helena Railroad v. Johnson, the Supreme Court of the United States was asked to decide whether a railroad company was liable for damages caused by a train accident.
Ivinson v. Hutton
119 U.S. 604 · Decided 10 Jan 1887 · Justice MillerIvinso v. Hutton was a United States Supreme Court case that dealt with the issue of whether a contract between two parties was valid.